Editor's Blog: Music, Memories & Management of a Digital Nature: Eugene Mulls the EMI-DRM Deal
Posted 04/03/2007 at 1:04pm
| by Eugene Robinson
For the first time in a long time I got the first time news of EMI’s recent decision to back off of, per the recent and possibly causally connected Jobsian request, their managing of digital rights for music, through RADIO, curiously enough. Sitting at the kitchen table with NPR churning in the background, there it was: EMI’s entire back catalog of music was being released into the wild blue yonder with nary a shackle. Gone are the cryptographic controls on access to your favorite Kevin Federline tunes. Yes. Now all the Marillion I could ever stand would be mine. Ditto, Victoria Beckham.
But after the expiration of early stage ebullience would we, us musicians I mean, be left with nothing but party streamers and a creeping sense that while something significant had just happened, something significantly wrong had just happened too? Well, what HAD just happened? In very simple terms when May 1st hits, when workers of the world are rising up as they do every May 1st, you’ll be able to celebrate the revolution, though it, in all likelihood will not be televised, with an iTunes purchase of a song, songs, or albums by your favorite artists with NO RESTRICTIONS placed on how you use what you’ve subsequently downloaded for the price of $1.29.
No restrictions. Wow. Yeah, it was really chafing my hide before when I couldn’t burn a disk myself and then pass it to a friend? Oh, wait. Nevermind. But the fear that we’d all start file sharing with our friends and that finally scuttling the great ship of state that is the music industry’s been overcome by some clear thinkers somewhere who have sussed out that maybe if you make it easy, quick, and of a certain quality (and the DRM-free stuff will be encoded at 256 kbps) that most of us who don’t want to steal, won’t steal and everything will be OK.
And I believed that until I found songs from my band's CDs being downloaded on some Eastern European site and while I did the quick calculations in my head it seemed that for Gwen Stefani, with economies of scale playing very much of a factor, everything would indeed be fine. But for my group who has never sold more than 20,000 copies of any single one of our releases, a high quality download to 5000 or so fans who might not be able to get or be able to pay for our music anyway, this represents a sizeable chunk of our revenue and maybe it IS different from buying one CD and lending it to your friends. I mean most of us don’t have 5000 friends, MYSpace notwithstanding.
So I did what any righteously panicked band guy does: call the guy who runs our label. Mark Thompson at Hydrahead Records. And I poured out my heart…if people with non-Apple mp3 players can now buy through iTunes, well this is good for us, but if for 30 cents more high quality copies can be stolen by our enemies in the east isn’t this something we should care about?!?!
“I couldn’t care less,” says Thompson. “I mean there’s a reason we’re selling more records, ACTUAL records, things you can hold in your hand, than we ever have. But I believe in true quality inspiring an appreciation for that quality and people paying for easily accessible music of bands they LIKE whether its online or not.”
Pause.
“That probably rules you guys out though.”
Ahhhh....Label: 1, Me: 0.