9 Advanced Techniques for Novice Filmmakers
You have the camera and the editing software--now what? Add polish to your home movies with these tips for better audio and steadier footage.
Apple’s iMovie and Final Cut give Mac users intuitive tools for editing their home movies from dry, amateurish “Wave to the camera, kids” productions into something that’s actually worth watching. But if you start with cruddy footage, there’s only so much you can do in post-production to improve it. Two of the biggest problems that can’t really be fixed later on are poor sound quality and a jittery camera. So when you’re ready to take your backyard epics to the next level, we offer the following improvements to your movie-making setup. They won’t break the bank, but they’ll definitely improve your work. Next stop, Sundance?

Adding a few more tools to your setup will result in much-improved footage and a better movie.
Difficulty Level: Medium
What You Need:
>> Camcorder to record your footage
>> Zoom H4 ($299, samsontech.com) or other audio recorder
>> Stereo minijack cable (1/8-inch male to 1/8-inch male, less than $2 on Monoprice.com)
>> Self-made SteadyCam ($14-$40, see Step 8)
>> Video editor such as iMovie (part of iLife '09, $79, apple.com) or Final Cut Express ($199, apple.com)
>> Audacity (free, audacity.sourceforge.net)
1. Get an Audio Recorder
Most professional cameras have XLR connectors for using professional audio equipment like boom mics. But if you’re a consumer or serious amateur, you’re faced with two problems: professional cameras and sound equipment are prohibitively expensive, and consumer camcorders don’t have XLR ports anyway.

The Zoom H4 will capture much better sound than your camera's built-in mic.
But that doesn’t mean you’re stuck with your camera’s built-in microphone. All you need is a separate device to record your sound independently. We like the Zoom H4 (samsontech.com); it’s got a novel way of positioning its microphones that leads to excellent stereo quality in a very small design. It’s popular with musicians, but filmmakers should check it out, too. The list price is $299, but you can typically find it for less online--and don’t forget eBay.
2. Pick a Recording Format

48kHz WAV is the way to go.
Switch your recorder on, and you’ll notice four buttons on the side. These offer you various quality settings. You could record in MP3 to save storage space, but because of a potential internal glitch we’ll mention later, it’s better to select the second button, set for High-Quality WAV format at 48kHz, the same frequency as your camcorder’s audio.
3. Don't Forget to Clap

Make sure your clap is ultra-visible to the camera. Don’t worry if it looks freaky--obviously, you’re editing this part out once you’ve synced the audio and video.
Before you start recording, think of what you’ll have to do once you’re in front of your editing program: your main challenge will be to sync your audio up with your video. But you don’t even need a real filmmaker’s clapper board for that. Your hands work just as well. Once your audio and video recorders are running, clap in front of the camera. Later, you’ll simply match the visual clap with its audio counterpart in post-production. Make sure each time you stop your camera, you also stop your audio recorder, which makes it easier to match the video clips to the right audio files.
4. Get Audacity

The open-source Audacity will solve our sync-drift problem.
When you’re done shooting, import your video footage to your Mac. But getting audio off the Zoom H4 is a little trickier. If you connect the H4 to your Mac and drag the files onto the desktop, you may notice something called “sync drift.” If you tried to sync it to your footage, you could match up the video and audio at the clap, but the sound would progressively and mysteriously (and infuriatingly) get further out of sync as you moved along the clip. For some reason, the Zoom’s internal clock is different from the Mac and your camcorder. The problem is easily solved, though: go to audacity.sourceforge.net and download the free Audacity sound-editing application.
5. Re-record the Audio

This extra re-recording step is crucial for avoiding sync drift.
Rather than connecting the Zoom via USB to transfer the audio, use a stereo minijack cable to connect your Mac’s audio-in port to the Zoom’s Line port. Turn the Zoom on, select the track you want to use, and press the Play button. As you do, click Audacity’s Record button. You’ll be re-recording your audio onto your Mac in real time, but taking the time to do this will completely solve the sync-drift problem. Once you’ve reached the end of your track, click Audacity’s Stop button, then go to File > Export. Save the file in the AIFF or WAV format to preserve its highest quality. You’re now ready to move to your editing program.
6. Audio-Video Sync in iMovie

The green bar is the sound; just drag it along the video clip until the sound and video of the clap match up.
Syncing the audio and video in iMovie is a little tricky the first time you do it, but it’s absolutely achievable. First, drag your video clip onto your project, and then insert the audio over that clip by dragging it from the Finder. Make sure the thumbnail slider is set to 1/2 to give you as much precision as possible when syncing the video and audio up. Next, mouse over the audio until you hear the clap--the audio meter to the right should also help you pinpoint it. Drag at that precise point until you locate the clap on the video. If you’re careful, you can be extremely precise. Finally, mute the video track’s audio (the audio from your camcorder’s mic), and you’re done.
7. Audio-Video Sync in Final Cut

Just match up the markers on the video (blue) and audio (green).
The sync process is much easier when working in either Final Cut Express (and naturally, this also works in Final Cut Studio). Start by opening the video clip in the Viewer window. Press the M key when the clap occurs. Repeat the process for the audio track, and add both to a sequence. The markers make it easy to line up your audio and video perfectly, and you’re ready to start editing with much better sound than you could have hoped to achieve with your camcorder’s onboard microphone.
8. Make a Cheap SteadyCam

If you don't want to track down the parts yourself, Lee's site sells a kit for $39.95.
Getting a static shot is easy: just make sure your camera is resting on something stable, like a tripod. Moving shots are much more interesting, but consumer camcorders are so light that unless you’re unbelievably steady, the camera will jitter, giving you shaky footage. Relying on your editing program’s image-stabilization feature is hit or miss--it almost always has to zoom in on your image, resulting in a loss of quality. You could also purchase a SteadyCam, which compensates for the camera operator’s movements and creates an amazingly smooth motion. But be prepared to pay thousands of dollars for one. Thankfully, Johnny Chung Lee was clever enough to design a DIY SteadyCam-like device, and posted instructions at 14dollarstabilizer.org. Head there and follow the instructions--the parts should cost you about $14.
9. Practice Makes Perfect

Steady, now.
Once you’ve built your homemade SteadyCam, don’t expect overnight miracles: You’ll immediately notice an improvement in your shots with more confident moves and very little jitter, but you’ll need to practice a lot for the best results. The device gives you a better hold and more weight to stabilize the motion. Once you learn to move with it, the results can be astonishing, giving you much more stable footage for very little money--and isn’t that what every low-budget filmmaker is looking for?
jbeaumont
November 04, 2010 at 2:20pm
This article is wrong in so many ways.
First, the Zoom H4 has been discontinued for a while. Why are you recommending it? The H4n is the current and much improved model. Also, as others have pointed out a good lav mic (or camera mounted directional mic) will improve sound with out all the hassles of double-system sound (i.e. a separate recorder).You say "the Zoom’s internal clock is different from the Mac and your camcorder" it's a lot more complicated than that. And unless there is a flaw in the Zoom's design this statement in incorrect. Sync drift is much more likely to be "operator error"
Re-recording into your computer! Holy crap what a bad idea. This will not solve the fundamental sync problem if you don't use the correct settings (which he doesn't mention) plus it introduces the possibility of all sorts of noise and distortion.
Typically the problem of drift is caused by setting the audio sample rate incorrectly. Final Cut will try and compensate by resampling the audio or play it at a slighty different speed. Either way you get drift.
A correctly set up camera (standard frame rate, highest quality, 48Khz audio) and an audio recorder (48Khz, 16 or 24 bits) will stay in sync for several minutes. (In other words if you use LP mode on your camcorder all bets are off). You need professional equipment to keep anything in sync longer than that. So why suggest double-system sound?I find it odd that Steve Paris is listed as a MacLife staffer but no e-mail address is listed. I would have contacted directly rather than calling him out in public but I didn't have that option.
MacWynn
October 06, 2010 at 2:20pm
Talk about adding too many steps. You can get great audio with a $20 lav mic from Amazon and avoid about five steps. Separate audio is more pro level. I see many novices losing their sanity over this. I have never been an "average user" but I know lots of them and for some, getting them to attach a file to email can be a hassle.
This is just bad advice for newbs.
MacWynn
mcjones
September 27, 2010 at 3:02pm
I realize the sound quality and battery advantage of using a separate audio recorder but for a cheapskates approach, would a mic plugged into my MacBook Pro's line in jack and recording in Garage Band work? Any problems that you might see occurring?
Steve Paris
March 02, 2011 at 1:10am
Hi McJones
You'd have to try it out yourself to make sure, but my only concern would be the noise coming out of your laptop. Mics can be very sensitive and some MacBooks' fans can be very noisy...
Your mileage may vary, but this could be a little too cheapskates :)
Log in to Mac|Life directly or log in using Facebook
Forgot your username or password?
Click here for help.

















