Jaggy Adobe JPEGs in Leopard's Cover Flow
Posted 10/26/2007 at 12:00pm
| by Roman Loyola

Cover Flow is a major new feature of the Finder in Leopard. It works similar to the way Cover Flow on the iPod works. It's especially handy when you're perusing a folder of pictures.
For the most part, the picture previews in Cover Flow look crisp, but there seems to be an exception with Adobe JPEG files. In my experience, when you look at JPEGs saved in Adobe JPEG format, the image preview in Cover Flow is quite jaggy.
This JPEG file came straight from an Olympus camera. It looks great in Cover Flow, a new way to preview files in the Finder. Click on the picture to see the full image in a new browser window.
I took the same image, opened it in Adobe Photoshop CS3, and saved it as a JPEG with the compression level set to 12 (I didn't do any image modifications in Photoshop). Here's how it looks in Cover Flow — a jaggy mess. Click on the picture to see the full image in a new browser window.
I was able to repeat this with other Adobe JPEG photos. I also found that if I open the Adobe JPEG file in Preview and save as a JPEG, the newly saved file looks sharp in Cover Flow. I suspect that Adobe does something to the preview that causes the jaggies. If you look at the Adobe JPEG image in Quick Look (hit the spacebar afer you select the file in the Finder), the image looks fine.
A reader on Digg asked if Photoshop CS3 was set up for Full Size Image Previews (Photoshop > Preferences > File Handling). It wasn't initially, but I turned it on and retested. It didn't fix the jaggy images.
The fix. According to Apple, if a file already has a preview, "Leopard respects the preview." If there's no preview, "Cover Flow will provide a large size preview." The fix involves removing the preview from Adobe JPEG files.
In Photoshop CS3, go to Preferences (Photoshop > Preferences > File Handling). Under the Image Preview pulldown menu, select Never Save. Then open the Adobe JPEG file and save it as a JPEG. The file will save without a preview, and Cover Flow will create a crisp and clean one. See below.
It seems as though the preview that Adobe creates is of a lower quality than what Cover Flow creates. Click on the picture to see the full image.
By the way, Leopard adds a white border to preview icons. When you save a file in Photoshop CS3 as a JPEG, the border isn't on the icon preview (see below).
Top: The JPEG file straight from the camera has a white border. Below: The Adobe JPEG file sans border.