Apple Off the Hook in Class Action Lawsuit
Posted 12/27/2009 at 12:00am
| by J Keirn-Swanson
While Apple works to get a few glitches ironed out in the graphical
displays of some of their 27" iMacs, a judge in California cuts the
company a break with an even earlier class action based complaint
regarding their monitors.
Almost a year ago to the day of the
dismissal, Aram Hovsepian filed a class-action lawsuit seeking $5
million for himself and users suffering from a similar complaint as
his. According to Neil Hughes at AppleInsider, the plaintiff purchased
his
computer, an iMac G5, in October of 2006; less than two years later,
Hovsepian alleged that vertical lines were appearing on his graphical
display rendering his computer worthless. He further went on to claim
Apple knew of the defect and took no steps to rectify the situation,
though he apparently overreached in seeking to include every iMac
purchaser in the United States in his suit.
A couple weeks back, that's exactly what the judge in the case, Jeremy
Fogel, ruled, finding the "class" to which Hovsepian claimed to be
filing for indeterminate, including those with as well as those
without similar issues. Apparently Hovsepian either has received bad
advice from his lawyer or himself has a fool for a client, being given
two opportunities to amend his suit and taking advantage of neither of
them.
This was no doubt of some relief to Apple, who found themselves plagued
with unrelated delays in shipments of the new 27" iMacs for problems concerning flickering or discolored displays. While it's definitely good news to get out from under a $5 million lawsuit, Apple users are known to be high maintenance types, and malfunctioning monitors aren't likely to win Cupertino any hearts.