Read It Later 2.2 Rejected Over Registration Concerns

It’s been relatively quiet of late in the world of App Store rejections, but an interesting one popped up over the weekend from the developer of Read It Later, the popular iPhone app which allows you to save text for reading at a later date.
The Read It Later company blog was updated over the weekend to report that the latest version, 2.2, has been rejected by Apple. The rejection comes as a surprise given that it’s what the company calls a “fairly minor update,” with the only “new” functionality coming by way of using the open source sharing library ShareKit.
Strangely, Apple has singled out a feature of Read It Later which is also shared by hundreds (probably thousands) of others -- allowing users to register for a service when the app is first launched. According to the notice received by the RIL developers, “Applications cannot require user registration prior to allowing access to app features and content; such user registration must be optional and tied to account-based functionality.”
Needless to say, the rejection on those grounds has come as a shock to the developers of Read It Later, who feel that it could have “major implications” -- especially since the feature has been there from the beginning.
“If that is true, then outside of games, almost every single popular application in the app store would be affected,” the company blog explains. “The Facebook app, Twitter app, Evernote app, Google Reader apps, and any other application for a web-based service that requires an account would be rejected.”
The developer is naturally hoping that the change of heart is a “simple misunderstanding” and not a policy change on Apple’s part. “I cannot imagine most companion apps to web services would be very useful without an account,” the blog post concludes. “For example, would you want to use an account-less Facebook app?”
Here’s hoping that Apple steps up and clarifies this potentially damaging new policy which end users have been enjoying for a long time.
Follow this article’s author, J.R. Bookwalter on Twitter
Imagine Engine
August 23, 2010 at 9:44am
I agree with Apple rejecting an app from a developer who forces users to first subscribe to the developer mailing list, etc before viewing the app contents even for a trial app. How else are they to know if it's a useful app or not? How are they to be assured from a small time developer that their information won't be abused (ie: sold to telemarketers)? There are sites such as MacLife, Hot or Not and Apple's own user forums that do the correct thing by allowing readers to view content but not be able to post comments before subscribing to the owner of that site. Why doesn't Facebook and Twitter apps follow this common rule? After all there's no reason why Facebook shouldn't allow third parties to search/view user info if the Facebook user opts for anyone to find them. There are games in the app store that may ask for a user info voluntarily if they want to subscribe to a mailing list or user forum. They don't force the buyer to subscribe before being able to play the game. If I was asked that I would be asking for a refund on my purchase.
ListerGuy
August 23, 2010 at 9:57am
Yes apps that are simply trying to harvest personal details like email addresses should not be allowed.
This is not that case.
Read It Later asks for a username and password, that is it. Not your name, address, email or anything.
You need that account in order to access your list because the whole point of the app is syncing that list between your phone, iPad, computers, etc. A lot of applications do this, mainly the ones that are built for web services. Think about the Dropbox app for example. The point is to be able to access the stuff stored in your Dropbox account on the go. It'd be worthless without an account.
MitchNetzer
August 23, 2010 at 8:10am
Is it ironic that I used "Read it Later" on this article? I LOVE this app and hope it gets re-approved SOON! So useful while on the go or at work and don't have time!
Log in to Mac|Life directly or log in using Facebook
Forgot your username or password?
Click here for help.


















