iPhoto '11 Review
Apple's photo manager goes big
The new iPhoto ’11 looks amazing—and that’s a great thing for software that helps you get the most out of your photos. But it’s more than just a pretty face, letting you actually do some pretty amazing things with all those pixels. Apple built in major enhancements to the full-screen mode, slideshow templates, and online sharing tools. But iPhoto isn’t just about zeroes and ones—’11 boasts improved book-design tools and a new letterpress-card feature for those extra-special anniversaries and events, making it that much easier and more satisfying to bridge the gap between the digital and physical worlds.
On the digital side, while the full-screen mode in the prior version was pretty basic, iPhoto ’11 lets you browse Events, Albums, Faces, Places, and Projects in this mode. It looks great, sure, but it also gives you that much more room to work with every pixel of your Mac’s display. There’s more than a hint of the iPad’s secret sauce in this new display mode, too. Albums now get full-size icons, just like events, so they’re no longer a nondescript set of titles in the source list. And you can skim albums just like you can events and choose your own key photo, which shows up as the album thumbnail.
While full-screen mode looks terrific, the navigation system is different from what you’re used to—and not always in a good way. The bottom of the screen holds five buttons for Events, Faces, Places, Albums, and Projects. Double-clicking an album name shows you its contents, and another double-click on a photo blows it up to full size. Backing out again requires clicking buttons at the top left of the screen. As a navigation system, it would be fine on a device based around a touchscreen interface, but on a Mac, it feels limited. It’s like iPhoto now has two separate, parallel navigation systems. For all its full-screen flash, some users will prefer using the standard view after all, especially for large-scale photo organization tasks.
The full-screen mode brings iPad/iPhone simplicity to the iPhoto interface. The editing tools have been reorganized into three panes on the right, too, which cuts the clutter. Note the quick photo adjustment buttons at the top of the Effects panel.
There’s no doubt about the effectiveness of the new photo-emailing feature, however. With email baked into iPhoto ’11, there’s no need to export photos to your email client. And eight great-looking mail templates can accommodate up to 10 images. The photos you select are laid out automatically, so there’s nothing you need to do except type in a title and message and choose a recipient. iPhoto uses your existing Address Book contacts and the email accounts you’ve set up in Apple Mail, so there’s no tedious setup process to go through, and everything just works. What’s particularly clever is that you can attach your photos at their original resolution or have iPhoto automatically optimize the message size to a maximum of 5MB to make sure it’s not rejected by mail servers with size limits.
iPhoto ’09 already supported Facebook uploads for online sharing, but iPhoto ’11 brings much better integration and synchronization. Once you’ve created your Facebook account in the preferences, iPhoto automatically downloads any existing Facebook albums, and from then on, any new ones you create are merged seamlessly with those you’ve already got. iPhoto ’11 uploads profile pics too and zaps single pictures straight to your Facebook Wall. iPhoto will synchronize your Faces data with tags in Facebook, and now any photo comments made by your Facebook friends show up in iPhoto’s Info panel.
If you’re more physical-book than Facebook, Photo Books make great gifts and keepsakes, and you’ll discover big improvements here. The new theme browser uses your own photos to preview your book, provides the ability to design double-page spreads, and adds a book layout mode that shows all your pages at once. The Autofill option has been enhanced so that it gives priority to the highest-rated pictures and uses face detection when cropping photos to make sure that people aren’t cropped out or chopped in half at the edges. The letterpress cards are a new addition, using special printing techniques to deboss the surface design and then digitally print your card. The books and cards look fantastic, and while most of us might balk at paying money to share our pictures when we’ve gotten used to sharing them for nothing online, the physical quality and feel of a professionally printed photo book is hard to beat.
The bottom line. iPhoto ’11 looks great, but the core organizing and editing tools have scarcely changed at all. It’s all about the souped-up user interface and the new, exciting, and easier ways to share your photos.
iPhoto '11
Intel Core Duo processor, Mac OS 10.6.3 or later
Enhanced full-screen mode. Great Mail and Facebook integration. New slideshow themes. Improved options for pro-printed books and cards.
Now there are two interfaces rather than one. Core editing and organizing tools largely unchanged.
PetercinKY
December 16, 2010 at 10:54am
I also found a number of problems with Iphoto 11. My most annoying was the loss of picture titles when creating a MobileMe Gallery. I only use Iphoto to create customer Galleries and to create Apple books. My workflow is Lightroom and PS CS4. I create password protected Galleries for customer use so they can let me know image choices ie picture DSC_1234. This was easy in '09 and didn't require a renaming of the picture to DSC_1234-12 for the reference to appear below the picture. The worst part of all this is when I sought Apple support I was finally told "that (the lack of unedited "titles") is an expected finding." Give Me A Break! This reminds me of the "if it ain't broke, don't fix it." Now, perhaps it should read, "if it ain't broke, break it!" Iphoto has a lot of work ahead of it (one would hope)
MACgyver
December 09, 2010 at 10:41am
iLife ’11 takes a few giant steps backwards. One of the most touted features of iPhoto’11 is the ability to work full time in full screen mode, however, you are now given no option to email photos from Apple Mail... only from iPhoto email using 1 of 8 different templates. If you want to email more than 10 photos or don’t care to use the templates, you are left with 2 undesirable options. First go out of full screen and drag and drop the photos you wish to email onto the Mail icon, and then proceed. However, doing this gives you a mail window with photos all crammed together...some side by side. There is no room given for captions using this method. So, you must waste further time using the Return key to space things out before you can type captions and send. (this is besides the fact that you had to leave full screen to do this). Another option is to leave full screen and open Mail and use the Photo Browser, then go to Photos or Events, then spend time locating the photos again that you had already been looking at in iPhoto a few moments ago, then drag them to a New Message window and proceed. Apple really needs to add the option to use either Apple Mail like before, and have iPhoto as a second option. No one wants to email using the templates 100% of the time. In fact I’d guess the templates will be used way less than half the time as are Mail’s Stationery options.
Another step backwards is the removal of the Copy and Paste buttons below the ADJUST palate. Now if you want to copy and paste adjustments across multiple photos one must either remember the shortcuts for those function or once again leave full screen and go to the Edit Menu to find “Copy Adjustments“ and “Paste Adjustments“. On my 24” iMac there is literally 5 inches of blank space under the adjust palate where the buttons should have been left!
Also missing at the bottom margin of iPhoto’11 is SET DESKTOP and SPLIT and the option to choose what you’d like to appear there as in iPhoto ’09. Now, to reset your desktop picture to another photo, you need to exit full screen and find it in the SHARE menu of all places. I had to locate it by using the Help Menu. The Split Events option is now in the Events Menu instead of easily found at the bottom of the window.
If some of these things aren’t fixed via an update soon, I will be returning to iPhoto’09!
rlscharf
December 04, 2010 at 6:40am
What hogwash, this is terrible software! I had to revert to ilife 09 just to get my photo library back (time machine backup). Supposed fixes don't work either. Now iLife 11 sits in my cd storage case until some real fixes are implemented. Obviously the author has not tried to do any real work with this new version. In a word, "SUCKS"!
maclover
December 03, 2010 at 4:05pm
Seriously, not even a mention of how you can't even view a picture in "true" fullscreen. This is a huge negative, and greatly distracts from the "fullscreen" that they advertise. I want to see the image fullscreen, not with 2 menu bars.
pemarsh
December 03, 2010 at 10:23am
The review from Rod Lawton regarding iphoto 11 is mostly glowing. However, unless your head has been in the sand for the past several weeks, you should have already known that there are multiple issues installing iphoto 11. Most remarkable is the fact that when it is installed, many customers have lost their entire iphoto library, permanently. Were you even aware that there was already an update published for iphoto, addressing this, and other installation problems? (The update does not appear to work). It is disappointing that your review appears so biased and very poorly researched. Try this for starters: Apple.com>support>discussions>iphoto...happy reading.
Hope you research your products better in the future!
Log in to Mac|Life directly or log in using Facebook
Forgot your username or password?
Click here for help.



















