|
NAME |
MOZYHOME |
CARBONITE |
BACKBLAZE |
DROPBOX |
SPIDEROAK |
|
Website |
www.mozy.com/home |
www.carbonite.com |
www.backblaze.com |
www.getdropbox.com |
www.spideroak.com |
|
Universal or Intel only |
Universal |
Intel only |
Intel only |
Universal |
Universal |
|
Pricing |
$4.95/month per computer. $54.45 for one year, $103.45 for two years. |
$54.95/year. $99.95 for two years. $129.95 for three years. |
$5/month per computer. $50 for one year. |
2GB free. 50GB is $9.99/month or $99/year. 100GB is $19.99/month or $199/year. |
2GB free. Additional space is $10/month per 100GB, or $100/year per 100GB. |
|
Discounts |
One-year subscription saves $4.95. Two-year subscription saves $15.35. |
Two-year subscription saves $19.95. Three-year subscription saves $34.90. |
One-year subscription saves $10. |
50GB for $99/year saves $20.88, and 100GB for $199/year saves $40.88. |
One-year subscription saves you $20 per 100GB of space. |
|
Trial |
2GB free (forever) |
15 days |
15 days |
2GB free (forever) |
2GB free (forever) |
|
Unlimited data |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
No |
Yes, paid per 100GB |
|
Web access |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
|
Backs up external drives |
Yes |
No |
Yes |
No |
Yes |
|
Backs up network drives |
No (MozyPro Server does, see Mozy.com) |
No |
No |
No |
Yes |
|
How long deleted files stay backed up |
30 days |
30 days |
30 days |
Deleted instantly |
Forever |
|
Supports versioning |
Yes |
No |
Yes |
No |
Yes |
|
Supports scheduling |
Yes |
No |
Yes |
No (instant) |
No |
|
Upload speed throttle |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
No |
Yes |
|
Free restore methods |
Mozy Restore client app, and downloading from Mozy.com |
Carbonite pane in System Preferences, and downloading from Carbonite.com |
Logging in to Backblaze.com and requesting a restore. You get an email with a link to download a ZIP file containing your data. |
Downloading from GetDropbox.com |
SpiderOak client app, and downloading from SpiderOak.com |
|
Paid restore methods |
DVD restore is $29.95, plus 50 cents per gigabyte being restored, and FedEx Next Day shipping rate. |
None |
DVD up to 4.2GB is $99. USB hard drive up to 500GB is $189. Both include overnight FedEx delivery. |
None |
None |
|
Extra features besides backup and restore |
None |
None |
None |
Syncs files across multiple machines (Mac, Windows, Linux). Photo sharing. Public folder for file sharing. Share folders with other Dropbox users. |
ShareRooms let people log in and access your files over the Web. Keep any two folders in sync. Save encrypted data blocks locally. Merge contents of two folders. |
Online Storage Battle: Which Cloud Back-Up Service Reigns Supreme?
DROPBOX
Dropbox
is the mayor of Sync Town, working like iDisk but more reliably. And
since anyone can have a 2GB account for free, there’s no reason not to
try it out. Paid accounts are $50 a year for 50GB of storage and $100 a
year for 100GB, so you might decide not to back up your entire hard
drive. But the sync and sharing services are the whole point.

Your Dropbox lives in your User folder and acts like any other folder in your Finder. We added ours to our sidebar for extra convenience.
Installing
the Dropbox client puts a new folder called Dropbox into your user
folder, and any files you put in that folder are synced to Dropbox’s
servers. You can access those files through a browser by logging in to
GetDropbox.com. You can also install Dropbox on your other computers
(even Windows and Linux machines), associate them with your existing
Dropbox account, and access your files from there. It’s meant to
replace clunkier methods, such as emailing files to yourself or carting
them around on USB flash drives.
Dropbox syncs your files
instantaneously--we stuck five JPEGs in ~/Dropbox/Photos, and they
appeared in our list of synced files on GetDropbox.com within 10
seconds. Your Dropbox folder contains folders called Public and Photos
by default. You can share files in the Public folder with friends (even
if they don’t use Dropbox) by emailing them a public URL. To get it,
just view your Public folder at GetDropbox.com, click the file you want
to share, and choose Copy Public URL from the contextual menu. You can
email the link or paste it into an IM chat, and your recipient can view
or download the file in their browser.

Any photos you add to Dropbox’s Photos folder also appear in an online gallery.
Drag some photos into
the Photos folder within Dropbox, and Dropbox creates an online
gallery. It’s not as attractive as MobileMe’s online galleries, but
it’s an easy way to share photos online—just email friends the link to
the gallery or right-click any photo and choose Copy Link Location to
get links to specific pictures.
You can also set up Shared
folders from which other Dropbox users can upload and download files.
You invite friends by email address, and they’re required to sign up
for Dropbox accounts. And if they don’t want to install the Dropbox
client on their computers, they can stick to the Web interface only.
Referring friends to Dropbox gets you each 250MB of extra free storage;
grab your referral link from GetDropbox.com >
Account > Referral
Status. You can earn up to 3GB of free space from referrals. Joining
other people’s Shared folders does affect your quota, since the files
in that folder now show up in your Dropbox as well.
In our
tests, Dropbox was smooth and stable. And it’s convenient: We added the
Dropbox folder to our Finder window’s sidebar, plus put an alias on our
Desktop. Status updates appear as Growl notifications, or you can see
them by clicking the menubar icon.
We especially liked how
Dropbox deals with conflicts. If two users are working on the same
file, whoever uploads it last “wins,” but the “losing” file is synced
to Dropbox and time-stamped with the name of the computer that did the
edit, so you can figure out which version you want. And we loved
browsing our files on our iPhone: Head to m.getdropbox.com on your
device, and log in to view recent Dropbox activity, browse your files,
and view images and documents right in Mobile Safari.
THE BOTTOM LINE:
Dropbox is incredibly convenient and useful, especially if you
have multiple computers and are constantly shuffling files between
them. The robust
forums (forums
.getdropbox.com) and wiki
(wiki
.getdropbox
.com) are great resources for
help and tips.
COMPANY: Dropbox
CONTACT: www.getdropbox.com
PRICE: Free for 2GB of storage. 50GB is $9.99/month or $99/year. 100GB is $19.99/month or $199/year.
REQUIREMENTS: Mac OS 10.4 or later
Super-fast
syncing across as many machines as you like. Easily share photos and
files with friends. Great Web interface, plus a client that integrates
seamlessly into Mac OS X. Universal binary.
Joining a Shared folder affects your quota.
![]()
SPIDEROAK
SpiderOak is flexible enough to back up anything, to share files easily with your friends, and to sync files between Mac, Windows, and Linux machines. It installs as an actual application, but it’s Flash-based, so if you use it on two or more platforms, the experience will be the same.

The Backup tab lets you select categories (to the left) or specific folders to back up.
You can back up as many computers, external hard drives, and network volumes and servers to your SpiderOak account as you want. The other services we tested don’t allow you to back up network volumes, but since SpiderOak sells storage in 100GB increments, you’re encouraged to back up as much as possible. You select the files and folders to back up in the Back Up tab of the SpiderOak app, or you can just click the checkbox for a preset category, including Dekstop, Documents, Email, Movies, Music, and Pictures. The preferences let you exclude files and folders by wildcard (filenames including *.zip, for example) or exclude files based on their size or age.

SpiderOak keeps all versions of your files, in case you want to restore an older one.
Once files are backed up to
your SpiderOak network, they appear in the View tab, where you can
browse the folder structure for each of your backed-up devices. Select
a folder to highlight the Changelog and Merge buttons. Merge does a
one-time merge of all the files in any two folders on your SpiderOak
network. The Download button restores your selected files to a location
you specify in the preferences.
Your files are encrypted with a
combination of 2,048-byte RSA and 256-bit AES and compressed, so you’re
not paying for more storage space than you need. When you change a
file, SpiderOak only saves the changes, so the data blocks for the
parts of your file that didn’t change aren’t backed up again. And if
you have a file on two machines and back up both to your SpiderOak
network, the file will appear in both machines’ View list, even though
it’s only stored on SpiderOak’s server once. You still see all versions
of your files under the View tab, and clicking a file with more than
one version displays the date each was updated, so you can find the one
you need.
Share sets, which are set up in the Share tab, make
chosen files and folders in your SpiderOak network available to anyone
via their Web browser. You choose a Share ID and Room Key, which are
combined into a URL you give to friends. And the Sync tab lets you set
up Sync sets, choosing two folders in your SpiderOak network that will
always stay in sync on the local machines. We used one Sync set to keep
our ~/Documents/Receipts folder synced between our home iMac and work
laptop, or you could sync a local folder to an external hard drive.
SpiderOak
even encrypts your encryption key. The company doesn’t know your
password, although you can set up a hint. SpiderOak employees can never
access your data—and if you forget your password completely, neither
can you.
THE BOTTOM LINE:
We loved the Sync feature, as well as
the ability to archive files to the SpiderOak network and delete them
off the local machine. If our only complaint is that the SpiderOak icon
stays in your Dock when the app is running, you know there’s not much
to complain about.
COMPANY: SpiderOak
CONTACT: www.spideroak.com
PRICE: 2GB free. Additional storage sold in 100GB increments, $10/month or $100/year.
REQUIREMENTS: Mac OS 10.4 or later
Back
up as many computers, externals, network volumes as you like. Combine
two folders with a one-time merge or a constant sync. Keeps all
versions of your files without duplicating data blocks. Doesn’t delete
files from your backup unless you tell it to. Universal binary.
SpiderOak app must be open all the time.
![]()
Home Sweet MozyHome
We
reviewed MozyHome in our Dec/08 issue (4 out of 5 stars, p67), and
we’re still using the service a half-year later. It provides unlimited
storage space, flexible backup options, strong encryption, and you can
order DVDs of your backed-up data, if you can’t restore files by
downloading them. We’ve included MozyHome in the chart below for
comparison’s sake. To read the full review, see
www.maclife.com/article/reviews/mozyhome.
Online Backup Services: How They Stack Up
You’ve read the reviews. You’ve oogled the screenshots. Now we offer this handy side-by-side comparison of each service’s features and fees so you get a clear view of how they differ. Happy shopping!
teedeedet
August 08, 2011 at 11:47am
"I use Iozeta. Not only does it do backup, but it creates a new cloud drive that I can share across my computers and phones."
"….That's a great feature. It works the same with Iozeta - Livedrive. "
jacky2000
August 21, 2010 at 11:05am
www.DriveHQ.com is one of the first few companies offering cloud storage & cloud IT Solution. It offers a lot of services & features that can replace your file server, email server, FTP server, backup system and share / collaboration system.
Users can use www.drivehq.com to upload / download multiple files easily; they can also drag and drop files / folders using DriveHQ FTP service or DriveHQ WebDAV service to mount remote drive. Moreover, DriveHQ has an automatic data backup program for Mac. The service supports PC, Mac and Linux, etc.
JohnnyBoyClub
June 24, 2010 at 8:09am
Well in a battle you can never win when they are so many software competing , everytime some of them will come up with something new to become better. I am using http://www.dmailer.com/dmailer-backup.html and i must say that they allways listen to their users choice and suggestions so that they will be happy aswell . And their software is free and their internet backup storage is cheaper than ever.
From my oppinion after i tested many of softwares out-there i allways camed back to Dmailer .
macelite0010
March 18, 2010 at 1:17pm
Has anyone tried out ArchCloud's backup software? It looks very usable and easy. www.archcloud.com
Maclover85
December 04, 2009 at 2:15pm
Interesting stuff, anyway for me personally I have stuck with carbonite and so far I have no reason to change my mind yet.
![]()
benet
November 10, 2009 at 8:21pm
Every little chat Salon 1000 ah!replica watchYou are my best's buddy
23fd3
chilipepr
November 04, 2009 at 3:11am
Get 256 Mb more space on a free Mozy Home 2 Gb account using the following link:
https://mozy.com/?code=D685JF
C. Jacobs
October 27, 2009 at 6:33am
I wish to see how CrashPlan performs in the cloud backup field.
quesonacho
September 24, 2009 at 6:17pm
I tried Mozy based on this review. I had trouble from the start - backups not going to their server, file retrieval failed. It never seemed to work properly. And when I contacted support, I was ignored. No response to my e-mails, no one answers their phone (kept getting voice mail). AVOID THEM. I'm trying Backblaze, hope they do a better job.
showcutter
July 10, 2009 at 9:35pm
Although the article covers several services for users to explore, I wish that SugarSync and CrashPlan had been reviewed. CrashPlan is an excellent software product with a myriad of options for backing up your data. I presently use it and am very satisfied with it. I use DropBox as well but for file syncing and sharing not backing up critical data. The DropBox forums have lots of comments about users having slow syncing issues when their entire users folder is being synced. DropBox chokes on huge file sets. I hope that a more thorough follow up article comes out that covers more software options and the issue of incremental file syncs that only copy the bytes that are changed in a file.
MikeSmith
July 02, 2009 at 6:16am
I recently tried the beta of Time Warp by Jumping Bean Software (JumpingBeanSoftware.com) to do offsite backup and have been very happy with it. I'm already using Time Machine for local backups, and this works with it. Uses Amazon S3, and backing up all of my data only costs a couple of dollars a month.
bbridgfo
August 21, 2011 at 7:19am
@MikeSmith, do you still have the Time Warp installer? If so would you mind sending it to me? Jumping Bean SW has disappeared and I need to restore my data! Thanks for any help. needtimewarp@gmail.com
edwinblaw
June 26, 2009 at 6:09am
Heartedly agree: only 2 apps. Not up to MaximumPC (your sister pub) standards. In Backblaze "Defaults .." review the indicates there were other reviews. What issue were they in?? At present I also use Mozy but it isn't as easy as Carbonite 'sounds.' Fortunately, so far, no need to restore. I also have Desktop HD running with Time Machine for each computer; but, Hurricane Ivan taught me the value of "off site" storage B.U. For a few bucks a month a "Cloud" is well worth it. Just like to be assured of using the best.
Ed
laptopleon
June 16, 2009 at 11:45pm
A roundup with only two apps seems quite limited.
I use Mozy ($5 a month, unlimited storage) for a year or so now, works fine, better than CrashPlan did, which I used before that. Then again, they might have caught up meanwhile.
doitonabike
June 16, 2009 at 5:45pm
JungleDisk is my back-up client. Buy the software and pay for the disk space you use on one of two server options. You can also configure multiple network drives on the same account. I think a licence covers up to 5 computers and you pay for what you store. Archiving files as well as back-up is possible and you can specify how many versions of files should be retained and for how long. Absent from the cost of all of the options is bandwidth. It's could be easy to exceed bandwidth caps on a first back-up, if you are a user who has limits and transfers a lot of data. In some cases, exceeding your limit can be very expensive. If it's an issue, spread your initial back-up over a couple of billing periods.
yuri1419
June 12, 2009 at 8:17am
The Dropbox and file deletion commentary is a slightly misleading. Yes, if a file is deleted on computer A's dropbox, it is removed on computer B- this is what synching should be expected to do. However, in your account's web interface, you can "show deleted files", and restore deletions from there. I'm not sure what their deleted file retention policy is, but I have an option to restore some files that were deleted 4 months ago.
andy
April 07, 2010 at 8:54am
It's great you have that option, I wish there were more web interfaces to consider it. Online data storage is one of the most effective solutions to prevent data loss but I still think there is room for better. People still lose data even online that's why data recovery companies even exist. We still don't have the perfect storage system, I am not sure we ever will.
Sigil
June 12, 2009 at 5:58am
Great reviews! I wish Sugarsync had been included in this "online storage battle," but maybe that is the review. Thanks for the info!
Log in to Mac|Life directly or log in using Facebook
Forgot your username or password?
Click here for help.













