Forums | MacLife
You are not logged in.
#26 2006-03-28 9:34 am
- iBubba
- Displaced

- From: central Iowa
- Registered: 2000-10-06
- Posts: 7109
Re: We are cowards, The French are brave
Farmerkev wrote:
It's strange isn't it, mankind survives for eons without medical insurance and now it's a critical necessity.
You forgot the important part about privatization of medicine so it's now a money maker, as opposed to a basic right. People need insurance, smurf.
"Hell, I'm sure Og had some cool way of banging two rocks together, until he took himself too seriously."
- Pithecanthropus
Offline
#27 2006-03-28 9:35 am
- Farmerkev
- Official Dementor
- Moderator
- Registered: 2003-01-03
- Posts: 18626
Re: We are cowards, The French are brave
iBubba wrote:
Farmerkev wrote:
It's strange isn't it, mankind survives for eons without medical insurance and now it's a critical necessity.
You forgot the important part about privatization of medicine so it's now a money maker, as opposed to a basic right. People need insurance, smurf.
I didn't say they didn't smurf for brains.
Do your part to combat global warming.
Eat a cow.
Offline
#28 2006-03-28 9:36 am
- iBubba
- Displaced

- From: central Iowa
- Registered: 2000-10-06
- Posts: 7109
Re: We are cowards, The French are brave
Farmerkev wrote:
iBubba wrote:
Farmerkev wrote:
It's strange isn't it, mankind survives for eons without medical insurance and now it's a critical necessity.
You forgot the important part about privatization of medicine so it's now a money maker, as opposed to a basic right. People need insurance, smurf.
I didn't say they didn't smurf for brains.
*getting jabs in before mods show up*
What the smurf does that mean? Is that even English?
"Hell, I'm sure Og had some cool way of banging two rocks together, until he took himself too seriously."
- Pithecanthropus
Offline
#29 2006-03-28 9:38 am
- Farmerkev
- Official Dementor
- Moderator
- Registered: 2003-01-03
- Posts: 18626
Re: We are cowards, The French are brave
iBubba wrote:
Farmerkev wrote:
iBubba wrote:
You forgot the important part about privatization of medicine so it's now a money maker, as opposed to a basic right. People need insurance, smurf.I didn't say they didn't smurf for brains.
*getting jabs in before mods show up*
What the smurf does that mean? Is that even English?
Of course it is, you want me to find you a link?
Do your part to combat global warming.
Eat a cow.
Offline
#30 2006-03-28 9:39 am
- Pariah
- James Carville Fan..

- From: Belly Of The Beast, Oklahoma!
- Registered: 2001-05-24
- Posts: 18426
Re: We are cowards, The French are brave
Farmerkev wrote:
Sternum wrote:
Farmerkev wrote:
It's strange isn't it, mankind survives for eons without medical insurance and now it's a critical necessity.
Back in the old days, if you broke your leg, the doctor would come over and patch it up for a reasonable fee and be on his way. Medical expenses remained affordable because they were controlled by a free market economy.
Insurance companies changed this by joining forces with pharmacutical companies and tampering with the prices. They jacked up the prices of pills, medical equipment, and malpractice insurance, which drove the price of medical expenses beyond the reach of the average patient. They also used connections in Washington to cement their hold on the industry through protectionist regulations and laws. Your broken leg now costs as much to fix as a downpayment on a reasonably-sized, middle-income house.
Personally, I don't want insurance. I think it's a mafia-esque scam -- pay now in case you'll get hurt later. But with prices the way they are, there isn't much choice. I don't know if universal health care is the answer, but the medical industry needs some sort of reform, and the insurance and pharmacutical industries need to taken down a few pegs.
Resedit ignorantly complains about communism, but the current system is about as protectionist and anti-free market as it gets.Depending on how far back you want to go, there was very little if any medication other than what the doctor made up himself. The doctor also couldn't actually do much more than splint a broken leg. The free market really had little to do with it.
As far as insurance, after years of it breaking me financially I was able to get one of the new HSA policies effective this month. I'd love to see that as a national model truth be told.
So whats your point about the past?
Its like pointing out there were no traffic jams before cars were invented.
"and it's not surprising that they get bitter, they cling to guns or religion or antipathy to people who aren't like them or anti-immigrant sentiment or anti-trade sentiment as a way to explain their frustrations."
Barack Obama
Offline
#31 2006-03-28 9:39 am
Re: We are cowards, The French are brave
Farmerkev wrote:
sturner wrote:
HSAs don't help much if you are poor. They are weighted more toward the rich. But most things are.
I have no clue why people think that, it's simply not true.
I'm broke and it's the only way to still afford insurance.
HSAs just work as a tax deduction right?
It's a paradox of how sharply dull I am.
Offline
#32 2006-03-28 9:40 am
- iBubba
- Displaced

- From: central Iowa
- Registered: 2000-10-06
- Posts: 7109
Re: We are cowards, The French are brave
Farmerkev wrote:
iBubba wrote:
Farmerkev wrote:
I didn't say they didn't smurf for brains.*getting jabs in before mods show up*
What the smurf does that mean? Is that even English?Of course it is, you want me to find you a link?
Pretty please. With sugar on top. I still have no idea, though, what "I didn't say they didn't smurf for brains" means in the context of being any sort of rebuttal to my statement.
"Hell, I'm sure Og had some cool way of banging two rocks together, until he took himself too seriously."
- Pithecanthropus
Offline
#33 2006-03-28 9:42 am
- bratboy
- laden with emotion
- Royal Wombat

- From: Austin, Texas
- Registered: 2003-01-19
- Posts: 34106
Re: We are cowards, The French are brave
He "didn't say" that people "didn't need insurance". . . S.F.B.
"One thing we've learned is there's a difference between being disappointed and having madmen in authority."
--Paul Krugman
Offline
#34 2006-03-28 9:42 am
- iBubba
- Displaced

- From: central Iowa
- Registered: 2000-10-06
- Posts: 7109
Re: We are cowards, The French are brave
Pariah wrote:
Farmerkev wrote:
Sternum wrote:
Back in the old days, if you broke your leg, the doctor would come over and patch it up for a reasonable fee and be on his way. Medical expenses remained affordable because they were controlled by a free market economy.
Insurance companies changed this by joining forces with pharmacutical companies and tampering with the prices. They jacked up the prices of pills, medical equipment, and malpractice insurance, which drove the price of medical expenses beyond the reach of the average patient. They also used connections in Washington to cement their hold on the industry through protectionist regulations and laws. Your broken leg now costs as much to fix as a downpayment on a reasonably-sized, middle-income house.
Personally, I don't want insurance. I think it's a mafia-esque scam -- pay now in case you'll get hurt later. But with prices the way they are, there isn't much choice. I don't know if universal health care is the answer, but the medical industry needs some sort of reform, and the insurance and pharmacutical industries need to taken down a few pegs.
Resedit ignorantly complains about communism, but the current system is about as protectionist and anti-free market as it gets.Depending on how far back you want to go, there was very little if any medication other than what the doctor made up himself. The doctor also couldn't actually do much more than splint a broken leg. The free market really had little to do with it.
As far as insurance, after years of it breaking me financially I was able to get one of the new HSA policies effective this month. I'd love to see that as a national model truth be told.So whats your point about the past?
Its like pointing out there were no traffic jams before cars were invented.
Let's no forget bartering. Or the intimate, small community where everyone knew - and basically trusted - everyone else. You'd make good on you debt, or word would get out and you'd be up the crick next time you needed help.
I'd gladly trade some design work for a physical or 'script.
"Hell, I'm sure Og had some cool way of banging two rocks together, until he took himself too seriously."
- Pithecanthropus
Offline
#35 2006-03-28 9:43 am
- Farmerkev
- Official Dementor
- Moderator
- Registered: 2003-01-03
- Posts: 18626
Re: We are cowards, The French are brave
kb5zhh wrote:
Farmerkev wrote:
sturner wrote:
HSAs don't help much if you are poor. They are weighted more toward the rich. But most things are.
I have no clue why people think that, it's simply not true.
I'm broke and it's the only way to still afford insurance.HSAs just work as a tax deduction right?
They work much like an IRA. It;s more complicated than that and I can explain it further if you want with my real world prices.
Do your part to combat global warming.
Eat a cow.
Offline
#36 2006-03-28 9:46 am
- Farmerkev
- Official Dementor
- Moderator
- Registered: 2003-01-03
- Posts: 18626
Re: We are cowards, The French are brave
Pariah wrote:
Farmerkev wrote:
Sternum wrote:
Back in the old days, if you broke your leg, the doctor would come over and patch it up for a reasonable fee and be on his way. Medical expenses remained affordable because they were controlled by a free market economy.
Insurance companies changed this by joining forces with pharmacutical companies and tampering with the prices. They jacked up the prices of pills, medical equipment, and malpractice insurance, which drove the price of medical expenses beyond the reach of the average patient. They also used connections in Washington to cement their hold on the industry through protectionist regulations and laws. Your broken leg now costs as much to fix as a downpayment on a reasonably-sized, middle-income house.
Personally, I don't want insurance. I think it's a mafia-esque scam -- pay now in case you'll get hurt later. But with prices the way they are, there isn't much choice. I don't know if universal health care is the answer, but the medical industry needs some sort of reform, and the insurance and pharmacutical industries need to taken down a few pegs.
Resedit ignorantly complains about communism, but the current system is about as protectionist and anti-free market as it gets.Depending on how far back you want to go, there was very little if any medication other than what the doctor made up himself. The doctor also couldn't actually do much more than splint a broken leg. The free market really had little to do with it.
As far as insurance, after years of it breaking me financially I was able to get one of the new HSA policies effective this month. I'd love to see that as a national model truth be told.So whats your point about the past?
Its like pointing out there were no traffic jams before cars were invented.
I was just noticing how it's become "critical" to our first world mentality. It wasn't always so.
Meanwhile millions are staving to death as we type this, I don't think they think health insurance is too critical.
Do your part to combat global warming.
Eat a cow.
Offline
#37 2006-03-28 9:50 am
- iBubba
- Displaced

- From: central Iowa
- Registered: 2000-10-06
- Posts: 7109
Re: We are cowards, The French are brave
kb5zhh wrote:
Farmerkev wrote:
sturner wrote:
HSAs don't help much if you are poor. They are weighted more toward the rich. But most things are.
I have no clue why people think that, it's simply not true.
I'm broke and it's the only way to still afford insurance.HSAs just work as a tax deduction right?
Sort of. The HSA we have here is a pre-tax deduction from payroll. Some employers match, some don't. Mine is throwing a lump sum of $1,000 in each employee's account - regardless of family or single.
My deductible is $2,750. Family deductible is nearly $6,000.
Your HSA funds can be used for anything related to your health care, including 'scripts, eye exams, dental visits, etc., as well as go towards paying the deductible. After the deductible is met, the insurance company takes over to [whatever limit].
The money is in a savings account for two years, after which it is automatically transferred to 401k-ish investments of the insurance company's choosing - I have no choice in this. This is where my underwear gets in a bind.
Additionally, though some HSA do offer prescription coverage, the one our company chose does not. One poor lady here has two special needs children. Our previous plan covered most of the 'script costs she had. Now, she out-of-pockets $900.00...
$900.00
$900.00 a month for these necessary prescriptions.
Last edited by iBubba (2006-03-28 10:15 am)
"Hell, I'm sure Og had some cool way of banging two rocks together, until he took himself too seriously."
- Pithecanthropus
Offline
#38 2006-03-28 9:54 am
- iBubba
- Displaced

- From: central Iowa
- Registered: 2000-10-06
- Posts: 7109
Re: We are cowards, The French are brave
Farmerkev wrote:
Pariah wrote:
Farmerkev wrote:
Depending on how far back you want to go, there was very little if any medication other than what the doctor made up himself. The doctor also couldn't actually do much more than splint a broken leg. The free market really had little to do with it.
As far as insurance, after years of it breaking me financially I was able to get one of the new HSA policies effective this month. I'd love to see that as a national model truth be told.So whats your point about the past?
Its like pointing out there were no traffic jams before cars were invented.I was just noticing how it's become "critical" to our first world mentality. It wasn't always so.
Meanwhile millions are staving to death as we type this, I don't think they think health insurance is too critical.
...and you have MANY people in America not starving, but very ill because they are choosing to eat instead of going to get medical care because they don't have insurance and can't afford basic medical care. I don't think a discussion about the woes of other countries' food supplies has much of a bearing on this domestic topic.
"Hell, I'm sure Og had some cool way of banging two rocks together, until he took himself too seriously."
- Pithecanthropus
Offline
#39 2006-03-28 9:54 am
- Onthebeach
- Member
- Registered: 2001-05-27
- Posts: 2037
Re: We are cowards, The French are brave
resedit wrote:
Pariah wrote:
Wonders when res will realise he has those choices because of "liberal" requirements set by state law.
I'm not opposed to laws just because they are "liberal".
Reasonably priced health insurance from the employer is a good thing.
Universal health insurance is not a good thing.
Universal health insurance will drive prices up and quality down, and it will be paid for by the tax payer. Communism doesn't work.
Well of course it will be paid for by the tax payer but is that automatically a bad thing if you are able to receive a decent level of health care for everyone? Prices going up is not a given though those opposed to health care for all would like you to believe that and the quality would not necessarily decline. Furthermore this has nothing to do with communism unless you think Japan, for example, is a communist country.
Whether or not such systems would work in the U.S. is another question.
If any ask us why we died,
Tell them 'Because our fathers lied'.
Kipling
Offline
#40 2006-03-28 9:57 am
- Farmerkev
- Official Dementor
- Moderator
- Registered: 2003-01-03
- Posts: 18626
Re: We are cowards, The French are brave
Mine of course is private and can build until I'm 65 in whatever I want, simple interest account or stock market or blend of both, all of my choosing. Even funding it is my option. The only limit is the amount per year that can be put in. It covers everything medical including OTC.
There is a lot more detail yet but it gets kind of long.
Do your part to combat global warming.
Eat a cow.
Offline
#41 2006-03-28 10:00 am
- Farmerkev
- Official Dementor
- Moderator
- Registered: 2003-01-03
- Posts: 18626
Re: We are cowards, The French are brave
iBubba wrote:
Farmerkev wrote:
Pariah wrote:
So whats your point about the past?
Its like pointing out there were no traffic jams before cars were invented.I was just noticing how it's become "critical" to our first world mentality. It wasn't always so.
Meanwhile millions are staving to death as we type this, I don't think they think health insurance is too critical....and you have MANY people in America not starving, but very ill because they are choosing to eat instead of going to get medical care because they don't have insurance and can't afford basic medical care. I don't think a discussion about the woes of other countries' food supplies has much of a bearing on this domestic topic.
Yes, the most critical area for Americans is those caught in-between income levels, too rich for medicaid and too poor for insurance.
Do your part to combat global warming.
Eat a cow.
Offline
#42 2006-03-28 10:00 am
- iBubba
- Displaced

- From: central Iowa
- Registered: 2000-10-06
- Posts: 7109
Re: We are cowards, The French are brave
Farmerkev wrote:
Mine of course is private and can build until I'm 65 in whatever I want, simple interest account or stock market or blend of both, all of my choosing. Even funding it is my option. The only limit is the amount per year that can be put in. It covers everything medical including OTC.
There is a lot more detail yet but it gets kind of long.
Does your have a limit? I can only contribute yearly up to my deductible (total, including the grand from my employer).
"Hell, I'm sure Og had some cool way of banging two rocks together, until he took himself too seriously."
- Pithecanthropus
Offline
#43 2006-03-28 10:01 am
- Farmerkev
- Official Dementor
- Moderator
- Registered: 2003-01-03
- Posts: 18626
Re: We are cowards, The French are brave
iBubba wrote:
Farmerkev wrote:
Mine of course is private and can build until I'm 65 in whatever I want, simple interest account or stock market or blend of both, all of my choosing. Even funding it is my option. The only limit is the amount per year that can be put in. It covers everything medical including OTC.
There is a lot more detail yet but it gets kind of long.Does your have a limit? I can only contribute yearly up to my deductible (total, including the grand from my employer).
Yes, that's the law for all.
Do your part to combat global warming.
Eat a cow.
Offline
#44 2006-03-28 10:02 am
- iBubba
- Displaced

- From: central Iowa
- Registered: 2000-10-06
- Posts: 7109
Re: We are cowards, The French are brave
Farmerkev wrote:
iBubba wrote:
Farmerkev wrote:
Mine of course is private and can build until I'm 65 in whatever I want, simple interest account or stock market or blend of both, all of my choosing. Even funding it is my option. The only limit is the amount per year that can be put in. It covers everything medical including OTC.
There is a lot more detail yet but it gets kind of long.Does your have a limit? I can only contribute yearly up to my deductible (total, including the grand from my employer).
Yes, that's the law for all.
Ahh... I see.
"Hell, I'm sure Og had some cool way of banging two rocks together, until he took himself too seriously."
- Pithecanthropus
Offline
#45 2006-03-28 10:04 am
Re: We are cowards, The French are brave
[Tycho?] wrote:
resedit wrote:
Pariah wrote:
Wonders when res will realise he has those choices because of "liberal" requirements set by state law.
I'm not opposed to laws just because they are "liberal".
Reasonably priced health insurance from the employer is a good thing.
Universal health insurance is not a good thing.
Universal health insurance will drive prices up and quality down, and it will be paid for by the tax payer. Communism doesn't work.Did you miss the thread comparing health care statistics? Where the US paid HUGE amounts more per person than countries with universal health care, yet had equal or worse benifits? I dont know why people say Universal Health Care doesn't work, when it has been shown to work very well in many different cases.
We don't have "equal or worse" benefits.
First of all - prescription drugs are subsidized in many of those countries - as in the drug manufacturer is not allowed to charge market value for the drug.
Additionally - it is not uncommon for the better doctors in those countries to come to the USA where they can make more money. Canada in particular has this problem.
Finally - having to wait for non critical medical service is not what I would consider "equal" benefits. I like being able to make an appointment because I have a sore shoulder and be able to see a doctor that week - not to get evaluated into a priority list, but to get the dang thing taken care of.
I'd be willing to bet that the US medical costs are also inflated by
1) A pill popping society
2) our general obesity
Both of those increase medical by a large amount and have nothing to do with private vs public medical providers.
-=-
Now - I do believe that all children should have medical access.
So should all adults, but children are more important.
For those who do not have adequate medical insurance available from their employer - there should be affordable plans that cover pre-existing coinditions made available at the state (not federal) level.
If you are self employed (like me) you pay fair market value.
If you are unemployed, it is subsidized by those who are employed. However, if you are unemployed, you should be required to demonstrate that you are going through steps necessary to become gainfully employed.
As far as children are concerned - I like the Colorodo model.
Someone from Colorodo can correct me if I'm wrong.
If you are not able to provide basic medical insurance for your child, that is grounds for social services to get involved. Now, Colorodo also has programs to help the destitute obtain that insurance.
In her right hand Jenny held the Bible of her mother
Jenny had a pistol in the other
-- Steve Taylor
Offline
#46 2006-03-28 10:10 am
- sturner
- Royal High Poobah
- Moderator

- From: Carrollton, TX USA
- Registered: 2000-01-31
- Posts: 13835
Re: We are cowards, The French are brave
Probably the way the plan is pitched.
I'm not dead yet.
There are 3 types of people, those who can count and those who can't.
"There are few things graven in stone, excepting your date of death."
Offline
#47 2006-03-28 10:10 am
Re: We are cowards, The French are brave
If you are self employed or your employer does not provide benefits (IE you have two (or one) part times jobs) one should be able to buy into the same medical plans that are offered by the county in which they live for county employees.
People who have disabilities that prevent employment - they get that coverage covered by the tax payer.
People who are unemployed get it but must demonstrate what steps they are taking to seek employment and become employable.
No need for universal health care, everyone has access to private health care.
In her right hand Jenny held the Bible of her mother
Jenny had a pistol in the other
-- Steve Taylor
Offline
#48 2006-03-28 10:12 am
- sturner
- Royal High Poobah
- Moderator

- From: Carrollton, TX USA
- Registered: 2000-01-31
- Posts: 13835
Re: We are cowards, The French are brave
In California maybe. Texas isn't so liberal, and Cobra is both expensive and limited in term.
I'm not dead yet.
There are 3 types of people, those who can count and those who can't.
"There are few things graven in stone, excepting your date of death."
Offline
#49 2006-03-28 10:14 am
Re: We are cowards, The French are brave
It's not the destitute that's having the problem - it's the working poor. Many people don't qualify for Medicaid, but still live paycheck-to-paycheck. Many people are being dumped off of Medicaid with no alternative. Employers are feeling the pinch and passing greater expense onto employees. The majority of the industrialized nations are free market democracies and still offer universal health coverage. The US is the only one that doesn't. Personally, I think it should be handled at the state level. But something needs to be done, soon.
It is an odd thing, but every one who disappears is said to be seen at San Francisco. It must be a delightful city, and possess all the attractions of the next world.
- Oscar Wilde
Offline
#50 2006-03-28 10:15 am
Re: We are cowards, The French are brave
Farmerkev wrote:
It's strange isn't it, mankind survives for eons without medical insurance and now it's a critical necessity.
Yeah, and life expectancy was... what? 24 years?
Offline
