Forums | MacLife
You are not logged in.
#26 2004-01-13 8:00 am
- Jehannum
- Banned
- From: Albuquerque
- Registered: 1999-07-24
- Posts: 8404
Re: Why do Mac video cards SUCK? & Why do they cost mega $?
Let me understand this:
You believe that since the development costs for a niche market are there, the people in said market should pay more? MOst of the code is the same. An opengl call is an opengl call. It's a standard for a reason.
But the interface isn't the same. You're going to have to trust me here, writing openGL calls to /dev/agpgart in linux is a *lot* different than writing openGL calls to the GDI in windows. What you're talking about is definitely not the same, although the language may be the same. What you're talking about is more on the application end, and if more companies wrote to standards like OGL, their client games/whathaveyou would be more portable, but that doesn't in the least bit apply to drivers.
While I gree that writing drivers, testing, debugging and so on can add to the cost of a product for another market, I do not agree that because of that we get the pleasure of paying a lot more a relatively small amount of work.
If the main interest is competing in the windows market, then the others will suffer, because they'll be left to amortize their own development costs, because the margins in the windows world are a lot thinner.
As a programmer, I can write programs for the mac or pc and it's really no big thing to do so. I charge the same rate regardless of what platform my client is on. I feel that is the way it should be. Writing code is just that: writing code.
The only thing a charge an arm and a leg for is COBOL and that's only if they took me out to dinner, bought me fat sack some beer and a "pro", then I might consider the offer.
But I digress, I think an increase in product price IS warranted, however not to the degree that it currently is. They know they can charge more, because we have paid it. Period.
As a programmer, I can write programs for whatever platform I want. I can use WxPython (even though it makes me feel dirty), and distribute the same .py files to wherever the hell I want, and so long as I build the interpreter into the install package, most people will be able to run it, regardless of platform.
There's a difference between doing that and writing a driver, though. Nearly every OS has a different driver model, and if someone were to abstract all of them to write a single driver, not only would performance suck universally, the cost for developing the abstraction layer would be enormous.
Again, it's a problem of "It's the software". There's no magic button that converts a windows driver to a macOS driver (and yes, they're of significant size, having to implement OpenGL, Direct3D, quickdraw, rave3d, and whatever else MS and Apple require).
"Goodness he just keeps going and going. He's like the energizer bunny of stupid." - Neut
Your powers are useless! I'm wearing my tin-foil underwear!
Offline
#27 2004-01-15 9:10 pm
Re: Why do Mac video cards SUCK? & Why do they cost mega $?
If I am not wrong. The only difference between the mac version of the Gforce AGP card and the Windows version are the drivers.
Drivers for windows are included with the card but the mac drivers come from Apple. Which are included with the Operating system install.
The video bios is also different. It's possible to flash a pc card's bios and replace it with mac bios, but it usually doesn't work.
Brandon
"Unfettered tolerance is the last gasp of a degenerating society"
-- Domus Aventinus, Foreseeing the Fall of Rome
Offline
#28 2004-12-14 10:34 pm
- Switcher
- Member

- From: Beantown
- Registered: 2004-02-18
- Posts: 1202
Re: Why do Mac video cards SUCK? & Why do they cost mega $?
Let me understand this:
You believe that since the development costs for a niche market are there, the people in said market should pay more? MOst of the code is the same. An opengl call is an opengl call. It's a standard for a reason.It is standard on the application side. There's hardly anything standard about it on the driver side.
As a programmer, I can write programs for the mac or pc and it's really no big thing to do so. I charge the same rate regardless of what platform my client is on. I feel that is the way it should be. Writing code is just that: writing code.
Yeah, and proting applications is relatively easy. Writing platform-specific code, partly in assembly, isn't. It sure as hell isn't a trivial matter.
,xtG
.tsooJ
anyone who can write in assemble is a god not The god but a god it is ver frustrating experience and i gave up
evolution of superstition
4 dear Easter bunny
10 dear Santa
20 dear God
Offline
#29 2004-12-14 10:48 pm
- XYZ
- Banned

- Registered: 2000-07-03
- Posts: 10881
Re: Why do Mac video cards SUCK? & Why do they cost mega $?
You can get the Radeon 9800 for the same price as, if not less than, the GeForce 4 Ti (only available direct from Apple, as an upgrade kit for supported computers, mind you, and thus not available at retail in any capacity), and it is today's technology
The 9800 is somewhat old, from what I've read. There's a newer-generation Nvidia card (I can't remember the name) that seriously outperforms it. But, it's an x86 card. There's also a new affordable Nvidia card that does much better than ATI's card in the same price range ($200, I think).
there's really no need for all of this
Offline
#30 2004-12-14 10:52 pm
- Switcher
- Member

- From: Beantown
- Registered: 2004-02-18
- Posts: 1202
Re: Why do Mac video cards SUCK? & Why do they cost mega $?
ok people wtf are you talking about I did newegg search up and down and wow
ATI 9800 PRO 256mb ram
mac 309.99
PC 290.50
wow what a price diffrence
??????

evolution of superstition
4 dear Easter bunny
10 dear Santa
20 dear God
Offline
#31 2004-12-15 10:22 am
- XYZ
- Banned

- Registered: 2000-07-03
- Posts: 10881
Re: Why do Mac video cards SUCK? & Why do they cost mega $?
This may be the card... It's a $183 midrange card that flattens the 9800 family
http://www.hardwareanalysis.com/content/article/1755.3/
http://www.anandtech.com/video/showdoc. … mp;amp;p=3
And, Nvidia has higher-end cards, too.
there's really no need for all of this
Offline
#32 2004-12-15 10:33 am
- XYZ
- Banned

- Registered: 2000-07-03
- Posts: 10881
Re: Why do Mac video cards SUCK? & Why do they cost mega $?
Look at how it kills the 5900XT!
http://www.anandtech.com/video/showdoc. … mp;amp;p=4
there's really no need for all of this
Offline
#33 2004-12-15 10:40 am
- Jehannum
- Banned
- From: Albuquerque
- Registered: 1999-07-24
- Posts: 8404
Re: Why do Mac video cards SUCK? & Why do they cost mega $?
Look at the date on the first post, too. The video card market was very different in January of 2004.
"Goodness he just keeps going and going. He's like the energizer bunny of stupid." - Neut
Your powers are useless! I'm wearing my tin-foil underwear!
Offline
#34 2004-12-15 11:04 am
- XYZ
- Banned

- Registered: 2000-07-03
- Posts: 10881
Re: Why do Mac video cards SUCK? & Why do they cost mega $?
Ah. I'm used to the locking of topics that are over 3 weeks old by overzealous mods.
Nonetheless, the video cards available for the Mac platform haven't changed a lot, eh?
there's really no need for all of this
Offline
#35 2004-12-15 11:12 am
- Jehannum
- Banned
- From: Albuquerque
- Registered: 1999-07-24
- Posts: 8404
Re: Why do Mac video cards SUCK? & Why do they cost mega $?
Ah. I'm used to the locking of topics that are over 3 weeks old by overzealous mods.
![]()
Nonetheless, the video cards available for the Mac platform haven't changed a lot, eh?
Well, the number of manufacturers hasn't changed, but their offerings have. You still get ripped off when trying to buy a high-end offering from either ATI or NVidia (though I think the only NVidia card supplier for Apple is... Apple).
I'm not particularly well-read on the subject of video cards, but I think the ATI X800 and NVidia 6800GT are the new flagship cards for both Mac and PC. The Mac market is achieving feature parity (if not price parity) with the PC market.
"Goodness he just keeps going and going. He's like the energizer bunny of stupid." - Neut
Your powers are useless! I'm wearing my tin-foil underwear!
Offline
#36 2004-12-15 11:28 am
- XYZ
- Banned

- Registered: 2000-07-03
- Posts: 10881
Re: Why do Mac video cards SUCK? & Why do they cost mega $?
There's no $183 6600GT, right?
That's what stinks. Not so many have the cash for the high-end card. And, that 6600GT performs admirably.
It stinks that the iMac is stuck with a 5200 "Ultra". Apple should have made the graphics card upgradable.
there's really no need for all of this
Offline
#37 2004-12-15 11:40 am
- Jehannum
- Banned
- From: Albuquerque
- Registered: 1999-07-24
- Posts: 8404
Re: Why do Mac video cards SUCK? & Why do they cost mega $?
There's no $183 6600GT, right?
Nope. I think they're >$400 for every platform.
That's what stinks. Not so many have the cash for the high-end card. And, that 6600GT performs admirably.
And that's why I don't buy on the high end.
It stinks that the iMac is stuck with a 5200 "Ultra". Apple should have made the graphics card upgradable.
I don't see how one necessarily follows the other there. Yeah, it sucks that the iMac is hamstrung (even to the point that it will likely not be OS supported in the near future, like my old 8MB Rage Pro iBook), but there's never been precedent for an upgradeable iMac.
It would be nice, for sure, though.
"Goodness he just keeps going and going. He's like the energizer bunny of stupid." - Neut
Your powers are useless! I'm wearing my tin-foil underwear!
Offline
#38 2004-12-17 2:51 am
- XYZ
- Banned

- Registered: 2000-07-03
- Posts: 10881
Re: Why do Mac video cards SUCK? & Why do they cost mega $?
Nope. I think they're >$400 for every platform.
Not the 6600GT. I found it on NewEgg for $183.
there's really no need for all of this
Offline
#39 2004-12-23 4:04 am
- aniarDS
- Member
- Registered: 2004-12-23
- Posts: 9
Re: Why do Mac video cards SUCK? & Why do they cost mega $?
they cost alot and they aren't great becuase the mac market isn't very big compared to PC, more manufacters=most competition and less prices
why can't Mac and wintel join forces to kick a certain penguin's ass? =]
Offline
#40 2004-12-23 11:59 am
- Jehannum
- Banned
- From: Albuquerque
- Registered: 1999-07-24
- Posts: 8404
Re: Why do Mac video cards SUCK? & Why do they cost mega $?
Nope. I think they're >$400 for every platform.
Not the 6600GT. I found it on NewEgg for $183.
Oh, my bad. I thought you meant 6800GT.
"Goodness he just keeps going and going. He's like the energizer bunny of stupid." - Neut
Your powers are useless! I'm wearing my tin-foil underwear!
Offline
#41 2004-12-23 3:48 pm
- XYZ
- Banned

- Registered: 2000-07-03
- Posts: 10881
Re: Why do Mac video cards SUCK? & Why do they cost mega $?
From the reviews I've read, the 6600GT is the best video card value, unless you have a lot of money. In that case, the frame rate offered by the top-of-the-line card outweighs the cost.
there's really no need for all of this
Offline
#42 2004-12-23 6:08 pm
- avkills
- demyelinated brain matter

- Registered: 2001-05-09
- Posts: 7088
Re: Why do Mac video cards SUCK? & Why do they cost mega $?
Does the 6600GT even work in a Mac? That is the better question. As far as I know all we have is the 6800GT and 6800 Ultra. The GT seems to be the better buy. Both have to be bought by Apple.
Although that PCI Sonnet card that works in PCI-X slots might be cool just to get usable desktop on another monitor.
-mark
Offline
#43 2004-12-23 7:05 pm
- XYZ
- Banned

- Registered: 2000-07-03
- Posts: 10881
Re: Why do Mac video cards SUCK? & Why do they cost mega $?
There is no Mac 6600GT, which is unfortunate, because it delivers the most bang for the buck in "PC" land, I think.
there's really no need for all of this
Offline
#44 2004-12-23 8:46 pm
- locutus_of_borg
- Knight of Mars

- From: Sparkopolis
- Registered: 2002-07-31
- Posts: 1499
Re: Why do Mac video cards SUCK? & Why do they cost mega $?
I couldn't figure out why the 9800 prices were sooo high... look at the date.
Yeah the 6600 is about the best price/performance out now.
And God said "taketh your rifles, all of ye, all but those unto the nation of California, for exempt must their rifles be and the resth are forlorn." So sayth the Lord.
Offline
