Quantcast

Forums | MacLife

You are not logged in.

#76 2005-01-04 7:23 pm

Steyr AUG
Agent Orange
From: 'Nam
Registered: 2001-08-24
Posts: 27535
Website

Re: The Pit Bull Problem



One thing pits do have going for them, however, is that they are invariably smarter than their owners. down

Theres something about this statement that just sounds so right. I can't put my finger on it tho.


Just like back in Saigon! Eh, slick?

Offline

 

#77 2005-01-04 7:28 pm

debbiedowner
Member
From: Pennsylvania
Registered: 2004-11-21
Posts: 2149

Re: The Pit Bull Problem

Theres something about this statement that just sounds so right. I can't put my finger on it tho.

I hate it when you agree with me, Steyr Aug. It means I must have committed some kind of sin.  twisted


Last edited by debbiedowner (Today 12:61 a.m.)
An idea is not responsible for the people who believe in it.

Offline

 

#78 2005-01-04 7:32 pm

Tria
Minor Prophetess
From: Madison, WI
Registered: 2000-05-13
Posts: 18087

Re: The Pit Bull Problem

Theres something about this statement that just sounds so right. I can't put my finger on it tho.

I hate it when you agree with me, Steyr Aug. It means I must have committed some kind of sin.  twisted

Welcome to the darkside.  The Manual of Style is currently on 10 month backorder.

Offline

 

#79 2005-01-04 7:33 pm

Kevin Woods
Member
From: My House
Registered: 2004-03-24
Posts: 346

Re: The Pit Bull Problem

When I worked in a prison the inmates would often say they wouldn't rob a house with a little dog in it. The big ones (dogs, not prisoners, but come to think of it ...) were usually very docile. Many of the prisoners (the nastiest ones, usually the rapists/ white slavers -- which was actually the name of their federal crime, white slavery, even if the "slaves" were brown or other) tended to consider pit bulls great pets, just as Pariah does. I've never met a pit bull owner I liked. There's always something very sick about them. ALWAYS. And they don't know it. They are always bullies.

BTW, anyone who wants to adopt a pit bull can come to the humane society where I live: The only animals there that are up for adoption are pits. Everybody else gets adopted right away.

One thing pits do have going for them, however, is that they are invariably smarter than their owners. down

I guess the little ones get attached to one person and shut out the rest. The big dogs do tend to be nicer.

The owner of the pits I was talking about in a previous post put out a sort of "Bad Ass" vibe. But when you live in Cleveland you have to get used to certain things or you could get hurt. I guess I never really new him that well. He could have been hiding bodies in the basement for all I know. We only new him on a neighbor level. We would wave and say hi and things. He was really nice to us. But the dogs loved to play together.  shrug


Pismo, 400MHz with 384MB of RAM and AirPort
4th Gen 20GB iPod
~ Kevin C. Woods  --;

Offline

 

#80 2005-01-06 2:56 pm

fortysixandtwo
Member
From: N. Cali
Registered: 2002-06-25
Posts: 665
Website

Re: The Pit Bull Problem

Well there is a degree of logic in the criminal sense that robbing a house with a stupid little mini dog wouldnt be a good idea. They are loud and anoying as hell, so if you are trying to pull off something stealthy then that wouldnt fly too well. It seems to me really that I would rather just rob a house that has no dogs period. But whatever.

Its no wonder the pits dont get picked up from the human society. Im sure most of them are young adults or adults themselves. The only way to properly raise an animal is to raise it from a very young age, and that is especialy true of pitbulls. THAT is the reason no one picks them up, because they do not know the background and have no idea what the dog is capable of.

Honestly, I have never understood the desire to own or raise tiny dogs. If someone can tell me any purpose, any at all, that a chiuwawa (sp) or jack russel or poodle or any dog that you can kill by kicking it hard serves, besides being a suburban watchdog, than maybe I will rethink it. But I swear to god, any dog that shakes when you hold it becaues its so smurfing energized needs to be eaten by a pitbull.

EDIT. I was thinking, and I realized most people are afraid of animals, so small harmless dogs make good pets for those pissypants out there.


"The cries of the carrots!  You see, Reverend Maynard, tomorrow is harvest day, and to them it is the holocaust.'"

Offline

 

#81 2005-01-06 4:02 pm

debbiedowner
Member
From: Pennsylvania
Registered: 2004-11-21
Posts: 2149

Re: The Pit Bull Problem

If someone can tell me any purpose, any at all, that a chiuwawa (sp) or jack russel or poodle or any dog that you can kill by kicking it hard serves, besides being a suburban watchdog, than maybe I will rethink it.

The smarter the dog, the more I like it. (I like all dogs; it's certain breeds' owners I despise). I got a poodle because I really do like dogs and also wanted the burglar alarm value. She saved us from a break-in when she was 6 months old (My Hero Dog!). More than anything, I needed a hypoallergenic dog that doesn't shed. One of my kids has terrible allergies to fur.

Now I have three poodles. The latest one is the biggest. Poodles are far smarter than any real dog breeds except for border collies. Man, border collies are amazing!  I think poodles are smarter than most people, don't take up much room in the bed, offer extraordinary comfort to lonely children and old people (mine do "volunteer work" in camps and a nursing home), keep you nice and warm during your naps, don't eat much, don't smurf much, don't shed, don't slobber all over you when they kiss you, are always at your side without being too emotionally needy (like Labs and other retrievers), and they tell really good jokes.


Last edited by debbiedowner (Today 12:61 a.m.)
An idea is not responsible for the people who believe in it.

Offline

 

#82 2005-01-06 6:22 pm

oatmeal
the clueless ones
Royal Wombat
Registered: 2002-08-07
Posts: 609
Website

Re: The Pit Bull Problem

... and they tell really good jokes.

confused

I guess I have to admit that I've never heard a poodle tell a bad joke. shrug big_smile

Offline

 

#83 2005-01-07 10:55 am

Regular Joe
Member
Registered: 2005-01-05
Posts: 245

Re: The Pit Bull Problem

I'm new here so I'll tread lightly, for now.  big_smile
I agree mostly with Og, despite his passionate use of language. Any dog can attack, Pit's attack more than any other dog and they are very good at it. This makes for a dangerous recipe. Yes, there are many other dogs that have attacked humans and yes Pits are treated far worse than many dogs. It is an unfortunate situation but dealing with the reality of the situation, Pits are treated more violently than most dogs due to their greater threshold of pain and they do attract people who want a 'tough' dog. The bottom line is basically this, if you have a Pit Bull (however you want to describe the breed) you and anyone close to you, are in danger of getting attacked and it will most likely be fatal. It doesn't mean it's a certainty but the statistics prove it is more likely than any other single breed. I have trained dogs and have studied both dog and wolf behaviors and know that Pit Bulls are a breed with certain characteristics, as a Retriever retrieves, a Pit Bull fights. It IS what they were bred for and despite the fact that they were originally bred not to attack humans, humans were also not part of the pack. The Pit Bull and the humans lived separately, never sharing the same living space. As we have adopted them into our homes we have made ourselves part of the hierarchy and made ourselves vulnerable to attack. One can argue forever about one's personal dog being a 'baby' and never harming anyone but I've owned both a Retriever and a Pit Bull and the Retriever has never once Retrieved a thing (lazy boot) and the Pit Bull has long passed on (of old age) without having ever attacked a single person. I was luck and very well informed. If my Retriever has a sudden urge to Retrieve, no big deal. I have kids now and will never own a Pit Bull again. It's not worth the risk.


Ha Ha...

Offline

 

#84 2005-01-07 11:42 am

oatmeal
the clueless ones
Royal Wombat
Registered: 2002-08-07
Posts: 609
Website

Re: The Pit Bull Problem

If my Retriever has a sudden urge to Retrieve, no big deal. ... It's not worth the risk.

It's all fun and games until someone has their fuzzy slippers delivered unexpectedly!  eek


Welcome to the forums. wink

Offline

 

#85 2005-01-07 4:32 pm

Regular Joe
Member
Registered: 2005-01-05
Posts: 245

Re: The Pit Bull Problem


It's all fun and games until someone has their fuzzy slippers delivered unexpectedly!  eek

Great, hadn't thought of that.  hmm
Well, there goes another perfectly good dog to animal heaven. (gets shotgun).


Welcome to the forums. wink

Thanks.  big_smile And don't worry, my dog's not dead. We just went hunting. Got some real nice bunnies to make slippers out of.  up


Ha Ha...

Offline

 

#86 2005-01-09 4:28 pm

Pariah
James Carville Fan..
From: Belly Of The Beast, Oklahoma!
Registered: 2001-05-24
Posts: 18399

Re: The Pit Bull Problem

I have said this before but each time I do its ignored so I will say this one last time and drop the subject.

I did not set out to adopt this Pit Bull, the situation was that either my wife and I took it in or the dog was going to the local pound and a certain death because unlike strays, the local pound immediately kills all dogs that are brought in my the owners. The 3 day wait is only to give people time to claim a lost dog so if the dog is abandoned there by its owner they are killed right away.
My original intent was to foster this dog only as long as it took to contact the local Pit Bull Rescue society and have them find me a home for her.
I was VERY leery of of having her around because, like pretty much everyone here, I believed the horror stories I had read and heard.
Being someone who likes to research things I began to look into this whole Pit Bull issue, reading and evaluating both sides in the debate. My original bias was against keeping this dog.
What changed my mind was that what I read on the "Pro-Pit" sites reflected exactly what I was experiencing in my own home while the "Anti-Pit" sites were mostly collections of anecdotes who's tone seemed along the same lines as most of the other hand wringing "everything is dangerous" safety nazi sites out there. Think Nader and Corvairs.

One thing I will agree with is that there really are alot of real smurfs who are attracted to Pit Bulls because of their reputation. I know because these idiots introduce themselves to me as I walk my Sadie. You find this in many Rot, German Shaper and Doberman owners as well.
Frankly most people are to ignorant and self centered to properly nurture a dog and when the breed is large and powerful that can lead to some real problems.
But the problem is a people problem, not the breed.
For example: Mastiffs are one of the 2 breeds originally used to create what has come to be known as a Pit Bull. Mastiffs were bred and raised to fight bears and if that isn't bad assed I don't know what is.
So Mastiffs have a deep and long breeding for blood sports in them yet are well known as being unusually safe and people friendly dogs. The reason that is is that for what ever reason, right now, Mastiffs haven't attracted the attention of the Macho idiots and the criminal underground that runs dog fighting. And thats not for lack of ability. I am confedent that a full grown, 200lb Mastiff would make short work of my Pit if so inclined. They are very brave and strong dogs.
If my dog showed the least sign of inappropriate aggressive behavior I would have swiftly gotten rid of her but not only does she not react aggressively towards humans she isent even hostile towards cats, which I think most here would agree is fairly normal K9 behavior to dislike cats.
Now rest assured, none of what I said above means I don't keep her under proper control at all times. That's something I have had drilled into my since I was the child in a family that raised Great Danes. None of our Danes ever demonstrated aggressive behavior but even still we always used caution and care with them around strangers. Along the same lines as a smart gun owner always treats a gun as if its loaded even if they know its not. The obvious reason for this is that even if you are 99% certain the consequences of being wrong make continual caution warranted.

But I am not going to be coy about wanting a large powerful dog as a pet. I am pretty sure if I had gone out shopping for a dog rather than had one given to me I wouldn't have chosen a Pit, but a Mastiff, Bull Mastiff, Great Dane or other large to giant breed would have been one of my choices. Frankly the biggest reason why I wouldn't have gone out of my way to get a Pit is that they are too small for my taste. When you grow up with Danes anything under 150lbs or so seems kinda puny and I have always disliked the more frantic personalities you find in alot of small breeds.
And I will not apologize for wanting a dog I can count on to guard my home and my wife and I. Companionship and security have been the role of a dog for many thousands of years and those 2 purposes are as valid today as they were in the caves.
Maybe I am just to used to being in the company of dogs that could easily rip me apart if they so chose. I have lived with what most peple consider huge dogs all my life, every single one of them fully capible of great mayhem were it not for good training and nurtureing.
I have owned Great Danes which are far more powerfull than my Pit and there werent any fatalities, I dont anticipate a problem continueing that streak.


"and it's not surprising that they get bitter, they cling to guns or religion or antipathy to people who aren't like them or anti-immigrant sentiment or anti-trade sentiment as a way to explain their frustrations."
Barack Obama

Offline

 

#87 2005-01-11 11:15 am

Regular Joe
Member
Registered: 2005-01-05
Posts: 245

Re: The Pit Bull Problem

I agree, people are the problem with Pit Bulls. We created them through selective breeding and continue to foster their negative behaviour. I remember 20 years ago there was a proposed ban on Dobermans. Like you Pariah, I have owned Pit Bulls and have fostered more dogs than most people see in a lifetime, most being Pit crosses. I've both worked and volunteered for the care of dogs and from my experiences most Pit Bulls are fine. BUT, if they are subjected to the smurfs that tend to be attracted to them they have a higher likelihood of attacking and killing humans than any other breed, including Mastiffs, which I've also fostered. Mastiffs were trained to kill other animals, not of its breed or family. Pit Bulls were and are trained to kill their own kind. In the mind of a Pit Bull (and any other canine for that matter), once we allow the Pit Bull to sleep, eat and coexist with us, we are of its own kind and become a target. A Mastiff doesn't look at humans as a threat or target because it hasn't been taught that we are so. Pit Bulls are taught and it is in their genetic makeup to kill their own. We have, through our own stupidity, lowered (or raised) ourselves to their level and thus have become a target. The Pit Bulls I've had in my home were wonderfully sweet dogs but one day, through my own negligence, I almost lost a foster dog. These two sweet lovable dogs (one mine and one a foster) ganged up on a larger and very non aggressive dog and tore it to shreds. It needed over 100 stitches and a blood transfusion. After the attack, they returned to their normal selves and were as sweet and loving as usual. If that would have been a human he/she would have surely died. Just because you have not personally experienced the unpredictability of this breed does not make it safe. It only make you lucky, smart and attentive. I never have, and never will leave any person alone with any dog and it sounds to me as if you are reasonable and very careful with the care of your dogs but unfortunately most aren't. The reason you always here "they've never attacked before, they're the sweetest dog" is because some dumb amateur has gotten ahold of a Pit Bull and have not take proper precautions to control it. If only most people were as careful and as attentive as you seem to be with the care of you animals, there would not be an issue. But since we live in the world we do, Pit Bulls are a problem. It's not pretty, but it's the truth.


Ha Ha...

Offline

 

#88 2005-01-13 10:39 am

elementforlife
Member
From: Falls Church, Virginia, USA
Registered: 2002-11-16
Posts: 85

Re: The Pit Bull Problem

i'm a proud Staffordshire Bull Terrier owner, and what I've read in this thread has made me absolutely furious.  Whne I get home from class and swim practice I will post.

You guys are biased, and what you say is ridiculous.  Any owner/former owner of a "pit bull" who was raised with them, will look at a picture of anyone's "pit bull" or variant and think "awww" and feel a real sense of love.


Element For Life Deck<BR>Tensor Trucks<BR>Bones Swiss Bearings<BR>Spitfire Wheels

Offline

 

#89 2005-01-13 11:43 am

Steyr AUG
Agent Orange
From: 'Nam
Registered: 2001-08-24
Posts: 27535
Website

Re: The Pit Bull Problem

i'm a proud Staffordshire Bull Terrier owner, and what I've read in this thread has made me absolutely furious.  Whne I get home from class and swim practice I will post.

You guys are biased, and what you say is ridiculous.  Any owner/former owner of a "pit bull" who was raised with them, will look at a picture of anyone's "pit bull" or variant and think "awww" and feel a real sense of love.

Perhaps you should read regular joes post.


Just like back in Saigon! Eh, slick?

Offline

 

#90 2005-01-13 5:03 pm

elementforlife
Member
From: Falls Church, Virginia, USA
Registered: 2002-11-16
Posts: 85

Re: The Pit Bull Problem

i came home to see that safari said there was in error in posting that, so i went back and re-posted...my bad...

thats what steyr's comment is about...don't understand why he feels he needs to belittle but you know...


Element For Life Deck<BR>Tensor Trucks<BR>Bones Swiss Bearings<BR>Spitfire Wheels

Offline

 

#91 2005-01-13 5:12 pm

Steyr AUG
Agent Orange
From: 'Nam
Registered: 2001-08-24
Posts: 27535
Website

Re: The Pit Bull Problem

Thanks so much for posting that again. It was inspiring the first time, now its just legendary.


Just like back in Saigon! Eh, slick?

Offline

 

#92 2005-01-13 9:00 pm

Switcher
Member
From: Beantown
Registered: 2004-02-18
Posts: 1202

Re: The Pit Bull Problem

I hate dogs


evolution of superstition
4  dear Easter bunny
10 dear Santa
20 dear God

Offline

 

#93 2005-01-14 9:59 am

Regular Joe
Member
Registered: 2005-01-05
Posts: 245

Re: The Pit Bull Problem

I hate dogs

Even hot dogs?  eek


Ha Ha...

Offline

 

#94 2005-01-15 3:27 am

bloomsday
Mmber
From: edge of ledge
Registered: 2001-04-13
Posts: 4040

Re: The Pit Bull Problem

Offline

 

#95 2005-01-15 3:29 am

justine
Elitist Beer Lover
Moderator
From: Sac'to
Registered: 1999-12-23
Posts: 28763
Website

Re: The Pit Bull Problem

That is so smurfed up.  neutral

Offline

 

#96 2005-01-15 8:34 am

dv
Negusa Negest
Moderator
From: Minneapolis, MN
Registered: 1999-08-30
Posts: 18091

Re: The Pit Bull Problem

That is so smurfed up.  neutral

But still a case in point - If I tried to do anything like that to another person, my dog would have mauled me.


"Now commences the process of cutting off the head, which generally takes from an hour to an hour and a half by an expert workman with a sharp blade." -Reuben Delano, Wanderings and Adventures

Offline

 

#97 2005-01-15 11:49 am

elementforlife
Member
From: Falls Church, Virginia, USA
Registered: 2002-11-16
Posts: 85

Re: The Pit Bull Problem

then again that is brazil where every dog owned is a status symbol.  They leave all these guard dogs outside in their little fenced "houses" and feed them when necessary.  I know, I grew up there, they don't know how to treat animals, or dogs.  Had that been any other type of strong dog, doberman, german shepherd that would have been the same case, I guarantee you.

I think my family owned the only kind, well treated "pit bull" (staffordshire bull terriers are actually lower to the ground, and shorter) in all of Brazil.  Probably the only well treated "fighting/guard dog" in all of Brazil.


Element For Life Deck<BR>Tensor Trucks<BR>Bones Swiss Bearings<BR>Spitfire Wheels

Offline

 

Board footer

Powered by PunBB 1.2.6
© Copyright 2002–2005 Rickard Andersson