Quantcast

Forums | MacLife

You are not logged in.

#1 2005-02-27 2:07 pm

sparkn
Conspirator
From: South of Canada
Registered: 2000-03-01
Posts: 3058

One more reason I don't like Windows

Jeezy Pete's Windows sucks.  I got a new laptop for my wife this Christmas.  She got a new job that requires her to have a PC so I got her the only one my credit could get that seemed decent (and the fact that the only credit I have that isn't trashed is Sears).  It's a Compaq Presario w/ AMD 64 3400+ (2.2GHz), 512 MB RAM, 80 GB HD, "SuperDrive", Blue Tooth, Wireless, 5 in 1 card reader, FireWire, USB 2.0, XP Pro, 17" BrightView widescreen, GeForce 440 Go, and does video mirroring or extended desktop.

Not a bad system as far as Compaq goes.  The battery came DOA, but HP took care of that.  The problem has been freaking XP shutting down Windows Explorer all the time.  At first I just blamed it on Windows.  I couldn't believe how casually I expect Windows to crash.  Today, I hooked it up to Airport for the first time and Windows consistently shuts down Windows Explorer like clockwork.  Instead of ignoring it, I clicked the little reference jin the Window to find out what was going on.  Imagine my surprise to find out that shutting Windows Explorer down was a friggin' FEATURE!!!.

The "feature" is part of Microsoft's Data Execution Prevention program found in the System Control Panel under Advanced/Performance.  Windows Explorer is being shut down because it's actions trigger DEP in such a way that it thinks Explorer might be a virus or participating in activity that a virus would.  What a crock of smurf!  Leave it on and I'm less susceptible to viruses and other attacks, but I have to suffer through Explorer closing for no good reason, or, turn it off allowing Explorer to function properly, but become more susceptible to viruses and attacks.

I told my wife "Thanks" for reintroducing the headaches of Windows back into my life.

BTW, as much as Compaq sucks, I really like the laptop.  Too bad it runs Windows.

Offline

 

#2 2005-02-27 8:30 pm

NoExit
NINJ4
From: Westmister, California
Registered: 2001-02-12
Posts: 6243
Website

Re: One more reason I don't like Windows

use firefox


[MA]NoExit|X| - The good man scorns the wicked.

Offline

 

#3 2005-02-27 10:17 pm

sparkn
Conspirator
From: South of Canada
Registered: 2000-03-01
Posts: 3058

Re: One more reason I don't like Windows

This has nothing to do with Internet Explorer.  This is WINDOWS Explorer. You know, Microsoft's version of the Finder.  Obviously, Microsoft thinks it's own applications, operating within it's own environment, subject you to being vulnerable.  I wasn't even connected to the "Net".  I was on a LAN (the Airport) browsing files on my Mac so I could show my wife how she didn't need to burn a CD just to transfer files back and forth.  I can connect to the network, but the moment I try and access ANY other system on the LAN, Windows Explorer shuts down with the aforementioned message box (unless I shut off DEP, which is way more than someone, especially my wife,  should have to remember to do everytime the network is accessed).

BTW, this doesn't happen accessing other Windows networks.  Just wonderful.  So much for the Trustworthy Computing initiative.

Offline

 

#4 2005-02-28 1:12 am

Altivec
I like fishy crackers
Moderator
From: Rat's Mouth, FL
Registered: 2002-01-27
Posts: 2361
Website

Re: One more reason I don't like Windows

http://windowsupdate.microsoft.com

Sounds like this... are you sure the laptop has SP 2 installed?

Offline

 

#5 2005-02-28 1:13 am

Bat
Flawless Cowboy
Royal Wombat
From: Björk, Björk
Registered: 2001-05-14
Posts: 28541

Re: One more reason I don't like Windows

This is the NX (No Execute) bit. It's new, only on A64 and the very latest Intel stuff, and there may be a bug or three. Some older app somewhere may be triggering a buffer overflow, or perhaps a bit of malware somewhere is trying to write to the NX region.

If you upgraded to 10.3.8 or whatever and some unpatched issue caused misbehavior, would you go ballistic over that? There'll always be trouble to shoot with new tech.


If all economists were laid end to end, they would not reach a conclusion - George Bernard Shaw

"Fire up a colortini, sit back, relax, and watch the pictures, now, as they fly through the air."

Offline

 

#6 2005-02-28 1:16 am

Bat
Flawless Cowboy
Royal Wombat
From: Björk, Björk
Registered: 2001-05-14
Posts: 28541

Re: One more reason I don't like Windows

Altivec wrote:

http://windowsupdate.microsoft.com

Sounds like this... are you sure the laptop has SP 2 installed?

That does sound a lot like it.


If all economists were laid end to end, they would not reach a conclusion - George Bernard Shaw

"Fire up a colortini, sit back, relax, and watch the pictures, now, as they fly through the air."

Offline

 

#7 2005-02-28 8:00 am

pillguy
Member
From: Houston, TX
Registered: 2003-02-01
Posts: 34

Re: One more reason I don't like Windows

sparkn wrote:

  She got a new job that requires her to have a PC....

I am an exec, and just took a new director postion in the Houston area (in healthcare).  The organization is a strick PC shop.  I told them I would not work for them and use a PC.  They eventually came around after I explained how OS X integrates with Active Directory,etc.  We finally came to a compromise, but they were floored that I would turn the job down for a computer. 

You better believe it.  I cannot stand Windows. 

My experience with it?  MCSE, MCSD, all the fixins.  I will never go back.  OS X for me. 


Just thought I would share.


"Be the change you want to see in the world" --Ghandi

Offline

 

#8 2005-02-28 11:38 am

BBq_Woa!
Member
From: Above
Registered: 2000-11-18
Posts: 2519

Re: One more reason I don't like Windows

This is yet another example of why people should get Sp2 promptly upon setting up new machines..

I win.

Last edited by BBq_Woa! (2005-02-28 11:40 am)


Athlon 64 s939 2.8Ghz -- 2GB Corsiar  --  400GBX2 SATA -- X800XT -- Audigy2ZS
Hitachi 1280X720 Projector
Klipsch Ultra 5.1

Offline

 

#9 2005-02-28 1:35 pm

IcarusFountain
Damned Portals!
Royal Wombat
From: Stuck in 1 Infinite Loop
Registered: 2003-12-27
Posts: 6253
Website

Re: One more reason I don't like Windows

BBq_Woa! wrote:

I'm a self-righteous child..

Fixed that for ya.  up
Nobody "wins"--its Windows, after all.  Don't "help" if you're going to (ignorantly) gloat over it.  Remember, SP2 already has its own share of bugs which haven't been fixed yet.  It seems that every time MS rolls out a new update/patch/fix, a whole new batch of issues present themselves.  So instead of giving yourself bragging rights by recommending the already recommended (albeit flawed as it is), try contributing something that hasn't already been contributed if you think it'll help.

"I win" is not the attitude we're aiming for in the MAF.  We're a community, not a competition.

Offline

 

#10 2005-03-01 2:07 am

sparkn
Conspirator
From: South of Canada
Registered: 2000-03-01
Posts: 3058

Re: One more reason I don't like Windows

The mapped network drive name does not contain more than 300 characters.  XPPro SP2 is installed.  It is an AMD 64.  It very well might think it is an "Access Violation", but a dialog that says something like "You don't have the permissions necessary" would be more appropriate, rather than shutting down Explorer.  This does not happen at all if DEP is turned off.

Bat:  What other app would be involved except Explorer itself?  All I'm doing is connecting to a Mac on my Airport LAN to share some Word files.  The WiFi software, possibly?

I was logged onto my wife's nonadministrator account on the laptop.  I should log into my admin account to see if it goes away.  Would it be safe (or safe enough) to just turn DEP off, or at least select Windows Explorer as an exception (I think only two apps are monitored by default, with Explorer being one of them)?

Offline

 

#11 2005-03-01 2:16 am

sparkn
Conspirator
From: South of Canada
Registered: 2000-03-01
Posts: 3058

Re: One more reason I don't like Windows

pillguy:

I'm not an exec.  Just an ordinary, struggling, lower middle class debt flooded victim of downsizing dealing with the bliss of ignorance and fear of the unkown.

Offline

 

#12 2005-03-01 2:13 pm

macfiend
Apply directly to the forehead
From: Los Angeles, CA on errf
Registered: 2000-05-03
Posts: 1964

Re: One more reason I don't like Windows

i dont get it? i am a graphic artist and we mostly use PCs. the place i used to work for used macs. i have no more problems with XP than OSX. thats not very often at all on either platform. i dont see how some curse windows so bad, i have no problems with it here or at the house doing "real" work, im in illustrator,quark, and photoshop ALL DAY LONG..ugh! its all the same to me, adobe apps are identical on either. as far as the OS its the same to me, no probs.


“You never get no back talk from no corpse”

Offline

 

#13 2005-03-01 3:56 pm

LLEVIATHANN
Itch you can't scratch
From: 22 Acacia Avenue
Registered: 2001-03-14
Posts: 7158

Re: One more reason I don't like Windows

macfiend wrote:

i dont see how some curse windows so bad

I find Windows machines much harder to troubleshoot when things do go bad. That is where my love for the Mac takes over. Booting to a CD in Windows for me has always been a crule joke. "Please insert your Recovery Disk now." Hahaha! Like I have one and even if I did I doubt it would be upto date. Then your stuck going about it the long way via the command lines/DOS.

This just happened to me last week. I was using tweakguide's XPSP2 guide to help optimize XP and turn off all the unused or unneeded services and what not. Things went well or so I thought until after the reboot. Upon restart I got a disk error "couldn't find bootable disk. The disk has been set up incorrectly and Windows can't find the OS" or something along those lines. I was like "Crist, this is a brand new install and now I just hosed it! WTF!"

Rebooted  and tried safe mode, Last Known....blah, blah, blah. Still no luck. Restarted again with the XP CD. Using the recovery console turned on all the services I turned off. Nada. Another and another and another restart with the XP CD trying various things. Gave up for that day, it was 2AM by then. On the next day I started at it again. Finally found the problem. The boot.ini file was hosed. I guess when I changed the default 30 secs to 10 secs that save messed it up.

It wouldn't have been so bad if XP loaded faster off CD, but no. Rereading your system config, installing the drivers. Hit F6 if you need to install additional drivers (I do w/SATA Raid). Hit F2 if you want the Recovery Console...blah, blah, blah. Hey Microsoft F this!

Wanna see your beloved Adobe apps go south with a simple mouse drag. Move'em some where else on the drive. Go ahead give your registry a heartattack. These are the things that make me scream at my Windows boxes.


Let us be thankful for the fools; but for them the rest of us could not succeed. - Mark Twain

Offline

 

#14 2005-03-01 4:03 pm

LLEVIATHANN
Itch you can't scratch
From: 22 Acacia Avenue
Registered: 2001-03-14
Posts: 7158

Re: One more reason I don't like Windows

sparkn wrote:

The mapped network drive name does not contain more than 300 characters.  XPPro SP2 is installed.  It is an AMD 64.  It very well might think it is an "Access Violation", but a dialog that says something like "You don't have the permissions necessary" would be more appropriate, rather than shutting down Explorer.  This does not happen at all if DEP is turned off.

Bat:  What other app would be involved except Explorer itself?  All I'm doing is connecting to a Mac on my Airport LAN to share some Word files.  The WiFi software, possibly?

I was logged onto my wife's nonadministrator account on the laptop.  I should log into my admin account to see if it goes away.  Would it be safe (or safe enough) to just turn DEP off, or at least select Windows Explorer as an exception (I think only two apps are monitored by default, with Explorer being one of them)?

Does the share have any forbidden chara. in the name? Like the slashes(/ \).

Yes admin privies could be part of it.

Another DEP & Norton issue. Did it come with Norton System Works?
http://support.microsoft.com/default.as … -us;873155

Device drivers know to have issues in XPSP2.

Last edited by LLEVIATHANN (2005-03-01 4:23 pm)


Let us be thankful for the fools; but for them the rest of us could not succeed. - Mark Twain

Offline

 

#15 2005-03-02 3:05 am

sparkn
Conspirator
From: South of Canada
Registered: 2000-03-01
Posts: 3058

Re: One more reason I don't like Windows

It has McAffe Enterprise Edition.  It doesn't have Norton anything on it, but the link didn't apply anyway.  It happened again today when I did my taxes online.  It seems Adobe Reader is now a disliked application for DEP.  I got real scared that I was going to lose everything because I was at the print a copy of your return stage and hadn't saved it yet.  I found I can ignore the close window and go about my business until I was ready to have Explorer shut down.  It won't restart Explorer until the window is closed.  This time I submitted a report to Microsoft.  I'm sure they know everything about me now considering the info took 10 minutes to upload to them.  I'm not worried, though.  My system's are all 100% legit.

I've been learning some more about DEP and I'm going to try a few things.  One thing is going through HPs update site and making sure all my drivers are up to date.  I also want to install some kind of spyware/malware detector/preventer so I can feel better about any DEP exclusions.  And, finally, I'll relax in front of my Mac and vegetate in these forums.  It's a shame I can't trust that laptop right now.  I really do like it outside of this problem (and Windows assinine implemetation of permissions... but that's another story altogether).

Offline

 

#16 2005-03-02 9:23 am

bobitt
Member
From: SEBC
Registered: 2004-10-04
Posts: 216
Website

Re: One more reason I don't like Windows

Sounds like Windows had the right idea with Windows explorer. It really isn't good for the OS.
More seriously, I believe you can disable NX...


Half Life 2 >> Halo 2

Offline

 

#17 2005-03-02 10:18 am

Bat
Flawless Cowboy
Royal Wombat
From: Björk, Björk
Registered: 2001-05-14
Posts: 28541

Re: One more reason I don't like Windows

LLEVIATHANN wrote:

Rebooted  and tried safe mode, Last Known....blah, blah, blah. Still no luck. Restarted again with the XP CD. Using the recovery console turned on all the services I turned off. Nada. Another and another and another restart with the XP CD trying various things. Gave up for that day, it was 2AM by then. On the next day I started at it again. Finally found the problem. The boot.ini file was hosed. I guess when I changed the default 30 secs to 10 secs that save messed it up.

It wouldn't have been so bad if XP loaded faster off CD, but no. Rereading your system config, installing the drivers. Hit F6 if you need to install additional drivers (I do w/SATA Raid). Hit F2 if you want the Recovery Console...blah, blah, blah. Hey Microsoft F this!

"It doesn't work any more. In newer Windows versions the NTFS file system is used, which offers numerous security features and other advantages. This file structure, which can limit access to certain users, also has a journaling function to restore data and supports encryption and compression without additional software. However, it also has a huge disadvantage: access from other systems, if at all, is only possible with special tools. In addition, access is mostly read-only. While that is enough to rescue data, changes to files such as BOOT.INI are not possible.

All of this means that in order to fix problems on newer systems, you need a few extra tricks up your sleeve. Let's take a look at some of them and how they can be employed."

http://www.tomshardware.com/howto/20050112/index.html

I have a Linux-based 'boot any PC' CD I got at the COD show a year ago. It seems to work well, tho I've not had time to experiment much with it.


If all economists were laid end to end, they would not reach a conclusion - George Bernard Shaw

"Fire up a colortini, sit back, relax, and watch the pictures, now, as they fly through the air."

Offline

 

#18 2005-03-04 11:42 am

LLEVIATHANN
Itch you can't scratch
From: 22 Acacia Avenue
Registered: 2001-03-14
Posts: 7158

Re: One more reason I don't like Windows

Bat wrote:

http://www.tomshardware.com/howto/20050112/index.html

I have a Linux-based 'boot any PC' CD I got at the COD show a year ago. It seems to work well, tho I've not had time to experiment much with it.

Nice! up

But the point I was getting at that it will never be as nice as booting to a CD on a Mac. It's fast, has a GUI and gives you direct access to your drives/files. It's like booting into Safe Mode, but on the Mac safe mode always works, unless there is some catastrophic hardware failure.


Let us be thankful for the fools; but for them the rest of us could not succeed. - Mark Twain

Offline

 

Board footer

Powered by PunBB 1.2.6
© Copyright 2002–2005 Rickard Andersson