Forums | MacLife
You are not logged in.
#1 2003-10-12 4:57 pm
- nexis
- Member
- Registered: 2003-10-12
- Posts: 3
Can Mac beat Windows????
Hello.
I am a windows user who has plugged in a mac cube to see if there is something there. Unfortunately, so far there has not be anything but problems. I trying to give this Mac a fair shake, but alas it has finally tossed all logic... right after my copy of final cut pro arrived. I thought for sure this would be where the Mac left the Windows machine behind. I didnt even get to open the box before the Mac gave me the Gray screen of death?
Heres what happened:
I installed X for pazzaz, I would tell you what version, but the machine wont give it back. I know it is not the latest.
First thing I notice is X looks good, 9 look bad. Second, when it boots, it seems to be booting in 9 then switching to X. it takes a lot of time to boot though, I thought Macs booted faster than Windows, oh well not this one.
Next I installed Wolfenstein, to see how it handles games, expecting not much because of the dated hardware, I was very impressed, not hardly a stutter except for saves. Mac very good
Next I notice when I return to play and load a saved game, this white box appears and tells me in many languages that I need to reboot. This happens alot. Mac bad.
So last night I was booting up which usaually take a long time of watching the little clock do its thing, but it never stopped. So I rebooted. this time the bong was immediate but there was no picture, then the screen turns grey, so I tried to reboot same thing. then I reach for the manual. I try shift boot, c boot with the X disc in there, (which it wont give back). If I let it sit a couple of minutes it shows this little folder with two face on it, looks like the finder icon i think, but it is grey and does nothing.
What is the deal, how do i get this machine to show me its greatness? I was hoping to use it as an editing station or maybe it would become my main squeeze, but..........
Offline
#2 2003-10-12 5:26 pm
Re: Can Mac beat Windows????
BAD RAM!!!!
that grey screen is a kernel panic, when that happens there is something whacky, mast likely the RAM is bad or some other piece of hardware is bad, though it can also be caused by doing major damage to the system files, but this is extremely uncommon unless there is bad hardware or bad system files invalid, on my imac it has happened to me 3 times, once because my hard drive died
Offline
#4 2003-10-12 11:38 pm
Re: Can Mac beat Windows????
Can you give a bit of history about this cube too? Ie is this something you fished out of a dumpster or something?
Did you reinstall X when you got the machine? Also it would help us to know which version of X. Click on the apple in the upper left and then select "about this mac" I highly recommend using 10.2 or later, and if you are using 10.0, you'll definitely see instability.
Its also likely that you do have bad ram, especially if after market ram has been added.
It's a paradox of how sharply dull I am.
Offline
#5 2003-10-13 12:35 am
- theanimaster
- The Animaster

- From: Bangkok, Thailand
- Registered: 2003-03-25
- Posts: 76
- Website
Re: Can Mac beat Windows????
A cube is very old tech these days. I wouldn't expect it to trounce a new Windows machine . . . except maybe in ease of use.
Old?? HAH! You wanna hear OLD? I'm using an Upgraded 7300 - Sonnet G3 400Mhz processor, Voodoo3 3000 PCI, Firewire PCI and USB PCI, OS 9.1 and....
well... i don't have that many problems with it... 'cept that it never restarts properly (gives me a high pitch beep and then stops... have ta turn it off then on again for a restart).
I've installed up to OS 10.1.5 on one of my hardly used hard disks -ever since i got a 30GB iPod - i hardly had a use for the second hard drive in the comp... so i decided to give it a go. Anyway, X got screwed by Norton 6.0 i reckon (on it's own... didnt run Speed Disk, mind you), and now i have to spend another 1/2 a day to re-install it with XPost Facto!
So - if you wanna talk OLD HARDWARE... let's make a swap! LEMME AT THAT CUBE!!! 
Offline
#6 2003-10-13 1:48 am
Re: Can Mac beat Windows????
Old?? HAH! You wanna hear OLD? I'm using an Upgraded 7300 - Sonnet G3 400Mhz processor, Voodoo3 3000 PCI, Firewire PCI and USB PCI, OS 9.1 and...
I have a Power Mac 6400/180. My fastest Mac is a 300MHz G3. 
Offline
#7 2003-10-13 3:16 am
- Ajax
- Member
- From: The middle of nowhere, I'm not
- Registered: 2002-01-24
- Posts: 145
Re: Can Mac beat Windows????
Old?? HAH! You wanna hear OLD? I'm using an Upgraded 7300 - Sonnet G3 400Mhz processor, Voodoo3 3000 PCI, Firewire PCI and USB PCI, OS 9.1 and...
I have a Power Mac 6400/180. My fastest Mac is a 300MHz G3.
Hey since you metioned it. I too have a 6400/180. I think the video is dead. Do you use the on board video or a PCI. Can you recomend a PCI that's not too expensive.
Thanks
What's up with those sausages Charlie? - Turkish<BR>Two minutes Turkish. - Charlie
Offline
#8 2003-10-13 4:49 am
- theanimaster
- The Animaster

- From: Bangkok, Thailand
- Registered: 2003-03-25
- Posts: 76
- Website
Re: Can Mac beat Windows????
Hey since you metioned it. I too have a 6400/180. I think the video is dead. Do you use the on board video or a PCI. Can you recomend a PCI that's not too expensive.
Thanks
You're lucky you found this thread then. Yeah, i'll help you out. The secret is a Voodoo card. If all of us Mac users knew about this years ago, maybe they wouldn't have gone out of business and the would would have been a happier place! Why? Because the Voodoo cards are the ONLY PC Video Cards that work - 100% on the older Macs! All you need to do is re-flash the ROM... and you can get the utilities easily on the net. If not, drop me an email.
Ok, enough with the rants. Basically, for older systems, the Voodoo 1-3 cards are known to work flawlessly. Im running a Voodoo 3 3000 on my system. If you want cheap - go for the same thing. There have been reports that a Voodoo 4 and 5 card might work... but heed thy warning - MIGHT work. I'd stick with the Voodoo 3 2000 or the 3 3000.
There. I had a hell of a time with this - because no one gives it to you straight out... not even the folks at www.xlr8yourmac.com.
[/b]
Offline
#9 2003-10-13 10:11 am
Re: Can Mac beat Windows????
Hey, nexis, while everyone ignores you, I sugguest you answer some questions.
First off, if you have a second-hand system, with a second-hand OS, I suggest booting into OS 9 (the ugly one) from a 9 CD, (hold C during start) and formatting (called initializing on this side of the fence) the master harddrive. (I think there's only one as it is.) Reinstall X only, without 9, I don't think you will even need 9, not even as Classic (OS 9 emulation within OS X. Sort of how XP Emulates 9x, but it actually works.)
If you stop getting erratic behaviour, it was probably the system. However, if it persists, replace the DIMM or whatever module is in there, and see if it persists. Then, you can start serious daignostics, if it still Mac Bad's.
Oh, and take a stroll to Apple-History.com, and see which machine you have. Usually simply by the processing speed, you will be able to narrow your machine down to 2 or 3 models (if not less.)
Once again, Apple Menu>About this Computer / About this Mac depending on what OS you do this in. For more, run Apple System Profiler (which is in your Applications/Utilities/ folder in X and right in the Apple Menu in 9.)
I hope some of this helps, and once you get the quirks out, you will have a system that you will enjoy very much..
If not, of course, I can always take if off your hands...
-tima
Offline
#10 2003-10-13 11:17 am
- ifdef
- Member
- From: Right here you fool! Quit ask
- Registered: 2001-03-28
- Posts: 135
Re: Can Mac beat Windows????
Basically this is usually indicative of a bad piece of hardware. I had similar symptoms when I had a bad harddrive once and another time after the computer got struck by lightning and had a bad motherboard, but the most common problem is probably sub-par RAM.
Before you go off on that troubleshooting nightmare you might try zapping the PRAM first. Then run the hardware diagnostics disk if the problems still occur. I have yet to have that hardware diagnostic disk ever actually find a problem, but still recommend trying it first.
I have a friend with a cube who uses it for video editing with iMovie, playing games, etc. It has _never_ crashed once. He uses it every day since he bought it new for several hours a day.
Basically, this is not usual for a mac and osx, and most likely indicates a hardware problem of some kind.
My OSX dual G4 500mHz (same vintage as your cube) hasn't crashed since I was a beta tester for OS X and found that rapidly unplugging and plugging in my Rio600 mpg player about 30 times could get a kernel panic. (something they fixed btw before the release)
Next I notice when I return to play and load a saved game, this white box appears and tells me in many languages that I need to reboot. This happens alot. Mac bad.
So last night I was booting up which usaually take a long time of watching the little clock do its thing, but it never stopped. So I rebooted. this time the bong was immediate but there was no picture, then the screen turns grey, so I tried to reboot same thing. then I reach for the manual. I try shift boot, c boot with the X disc in there, (which it wont give back). If I let it sit a couple of minutes it shows this little folder with two face on it, looks like the finder icon i think, but it is grey and does nothing.
What is the deal, how do i get this machine to show me its greatness? I was hoping to use it as an editing station or maybe it would become my main squeeze, but..........
Offline
#11 2003-10-13 11:34 am
- bvfd123
- Member
- From: CT
- Registered: 2003-04-06
- Posts: 381
Re: Can Mac beat Windows????
found that rapidly unplugging and plugging in my Rio600 mpg player about 30 times could get a kernel panic. (something they fixed btw before the release)
how did you discover this problem, do you commonly plug and unplug your devices?
24 inch iMac C2D/2.8 Ghz/2 GB/320 GB
MacBook/1.83 CD/1GB/160GB
Offline
#12 2003-10-13 11:59 am
- ifdef
- Member
- From: Right here you fool! Quit ask
- Registered: 2001-03-28
- Posts: 135
Re: Can Mac beat Windows????
found that rapidly unplugging and plugging in my Rio600 mpg player about 30 times could get a kernel panic. (something they fixed btw before the release)
how did you discover this problem, do you commonly plug and unplug your devices?
Heh, I took my beta testing really seriously!
The key was _rapidly_ unplugging/plugging it. You had to do it pretty fast to get the kernel panic. I tried a lot of other really goofy and silly things to get a kernel panic, but that was the only one that worked.
Offline
#13 2003-10-13 12:23 pm
- macfreak880
- Member
- Registered: 2002-10-14
- Posts: 950
Re: Can Mac beat Windows????
found that rapidly unplugging and plugging in my Rio600 mpg player about 30 times could get a kernel panic. (something they fixed btw before the release)
how did you discover this problem, do you commonly plug and unplug your devices?
Heh, I took my beta testing really seriously!
![]()
The key was _rapidly_ unplugging/plugging it. You had to do it pretty fast to get the kernel panic. I tried a lot of other really goofy and silly things to get a kernel panic, but that was the only one that worked.
It's good to know that if I ever need to plug and unplug somedevice 30 time in rapid succession that my os won't crash. I'm surprised that this hasn't come up in the OS X vs. XP debates yet. 
"Intel Inside" Not a marketing gimmick, but a warning label.
Offline
#14 2003-10-13 1:31 pm
- -Addict-
- Member
- From: Minneapolis
- Registered: 2001-04-13
- Posts: 358
Re: Can Mac beat Windows????
Well, my fastest mac is 266 mhz so there! And I still use my LC III so haha and a 200 mhz 603e PM 4400 for all my gaming needs. Beat that Old Schoolz
-------------------------------------------------------
No me jodes, soy el rey!
Offline
#15 2003-10-13 2:00 pm
- Marc
- On the run from the MPAA

- Registered: 2003-05-10
- Posts: 13129
Re: Can Mac beat Windows????
I can emulate all the old systems on my G5... beat that
You know the hole, the one you put the pie in?
My mean my pie-hole?
Yeah, shut it.
Offline
#16 2003-10-13 5:54 pm
Re: Can Mac beat Windows????
I can emulate all the old systems on my G5... beat that
I will. In March. 
Offline
#17 2003-10-13 6:17 pm
- Blandford Fly
- Member

- From: Malformed People Factory
- Registered: 2003-04-04
- Posts: 2142
Re: Can Mac beat Windows????
I can emulate all the old systems on my G5... beat that
My slowest Mac is a Classic II. My fastest is a G4 1.25 PowerBook with go faster stripes.
MacBook 2Ghz, 4GB RAM, OS X 10.6.1
12" G4 1Ghz PowerBook, 768mb RAM, OS X 10.4.11
Offline
#18 2003-10-13 9:00 pm
Re: Can Mac beat Windows????
Does is go any faster? I have some Neon and Civic enthusiasts thank seem to think the same thing.
Only they do it in form of 'performance' stickers, when the actual hardware is missing from the vehicle.
-Tim
Offline
#19 2003-10-13 11:29 pm
- nexis
- Member
- Registered: 2003-10-12
- Posts: 3
Re: Can Mac beat Windows????
Ok guys, I have the cube manual and I went through it before I posted. Remember I am a windows user, these type of problems used to be the norm. I have tried reseting, I fed the X disc in and tried boot with the c key held down, I tried the pram reset, hell I tried the shift key hold down boot. Damn you guys got a lot of ways to boot this "trouble free" system. Anyways its not a trash can find. I bought it as a display model after they came it out, thought about using it on my spare desk, but lack of software left it sitting forgotten, till I got into video editting. So I was back.
I would tell you what version of X I have but it wont give it back, I punch the eject key and it wont do anything, on or off. I am thinkin it 10.2, not postive.
I have also tried the 3 pieces of ram in various combos, no good. I am not really into buying more till I know this machine will work. I really have a hard time believing all 3 went bad at once. Also if the hard drive were dead, wouldnt it still boot from the X disc? 
Offline
#20 2003-10-13 11:34 pm
- theanimaster
- The Animaster

- From: Bangkok, Thailand
- Registered: 2003-03-25
- Posts: 76
- Website
Re: Can Mac beat Windows????
Well, my fastest mac is 266 mhz so there! And I still use my LC III so haha and a 200 mhz 603e PM 4400 for all my gaming needs. Beat that Old Schoolz
Already have. Sorry - i forgot to mention that my first Mac was a Mac Plus in '86 (this is what got me started), and later on, a Powermac 6100/60, which we later upgraded to a Sonnet 266Mhz G3. We also have an LC IIi laying around collection dust with the 'Plus.
Oh... and before that, i was programming a SHARP MZ-80A. Note that i was a 6 year old boy then... thing is, it's hard to keep up with the times and i've abandoned programming since the Mac came out, and instead im doing animation and graphic design. Funny how the mac changes the course of your future. If not for the Mac, i would probably be some code cracker, serial hacker or something as devious.
The Mac has saved my soul.
Now im a 2 year old adult 
Offline
#21 2003-10-13 11:46 pm
- theanimaster
- The Animaster

- From: Bangkok, Thailand
- Registered: 2003-03-25
- Posts: 76
- Website
Re: Can Mac beat Windows????
Well, my fastest mac is 266 mhz so there! And I still use my LC III so haha and a 200 mhz 603e PM 4400 for all my gaming needs. Beat that Old Schoolz
Already have. Sorry - i forgot to mention that my first Mac was a Mac Plus in '86 (this is what got me started), and later on, a Powermac 6100/60, which we later upgraded to a Sonnet 266Mhz G3. We also have an LC IIi laying around collection dust with the 'Plus.
Oh... and before that, i was programming a SHARP MZ-80A. Note that i was a 6 year old boy then... thing is, it's hard to keep up with the times and i've abandoned programming since the Mac came out, and instead im doing animation and graphic design. Funny how the mac changes the course of your future. If not for the Mac, i would probably be some code cracker, serial hacker or something as devious.
The Mac has saved my soul.
Now im a 2 year old adult 
Offline
#22 2003-10-14 5:01 am
- Ajax
- Member
- From: The middle of nowhere, I'm not
- Registered: 2002-01-24
- Posts: 145
Re: Can Mac beat Windows????
Hey since you metioned it. I too have a 6400/180. I think the video is dead. Do you use the on board video or a PCI. Can you recomend a PCI that's not too expensive.
ThanksYou're lucky you found this thread then. Yeah, i'll help you out. The secret is a Voodoo card. If all of us Mac users knew about this years ago, maybe they wouldn't have gone out of business and the would would have been a happier place! Why? Because the Voodoo cards are the ONLY PC Video Cards that work - 100% on the older Macs! All you need to do is re-flash the ROM... and you can get the utilities easily on the net. If not, drop me an email.
Ok, enough with the rants. Basically, for older systems, the Voodoo 1-3 cards are known to work flawlessly. Im running a Voodoo 3 3000 on my system. If you want cheap - go for the same thing. There have been reports that a Voodoo 4 and 5 card might work... but heed thy warning - MIGHT work. I'd stick with the Voodoo 3 2000 or the 3 3000.
There. I had a hell of a time with this - because no one gives it to you straight out... not even the folks at www.xlr8yourmac.com.
[/b]
Thank you very much. I'll give it a try.
What's up with those sausages Charlie? - Turkish<BR>Two minutes Turkish. - Charlie
Offline
#23 2003-10-14 6:06 am
Re: Can Mac beat Windows????
Ok guys, I have the cube manual and I went through it before I posted. Remember I am a windows user, these type of problems used to be the norm. I have tried reseting, I fed the X disc in and tried boot with the c key held down, I tried the pram reset, hell I tried the shift key hold down boot. Damn you guys got a lot of ways to boot this "trouble free" system. Anyways its not a trash can find. I bought it as a display model after they came it out, thought about using it on my spare desk, but lack of software left it sitting forgotten, till I got into video editting. So I was back.
I would tell you what version of X I have but it wont give it back, I punch the eject key and it wont do anything, on or off. I am thinkin it 10.2, not postive.
I have also tried the 3 pieces of ram in various combos, no good. I am not really into buying more till I know this machine will work. I really have a hard time believing all 3 went bad at once. Also if the hard drive were dead, wouldnt it still boot from the X disc?
Wow, completely dead? That could have something to do with its life as a display model.
Holding down the mouse button while restarting should make it eject the CD.
Offline
#24 2003-10-14 9:54 am
- frankly
- Greetings Citizens!

- Registered: 2000-09-16
- Posts: 5120
Re: Can Mac beat Windows????
![]()
Next I notice when I return to play and load a saved game, this white box appears and tells me in many languages that I need to reboot. This happens alot. Mac bad.
You definitely have 10.2 if you are seeing this white box with many languages because kernel panics prior to 10.2 would simply dump register and stack information onto the screen.
I would highly reccomend two things to see if you can figure out what is wrong with this Mac.
1) Boot from the OS 9 cd and use Disk Utility and Disk First Aid to check the status of your hard drive. If you are able to do this I would also reccomend reformatting the hard drive.
2) Boot from the Hardware Test CD and see if you find anything wrong then.
We don't know what is on this Mac or what condition it is in. I have been using Macs for a long time and if I had your machine in front of me I would want to start from scratch and I would begin with the two items listed above.
Later, Frank
xkcd: Listen to Yourself
There are only 10 types of people in the world: those who understand binary and those who don't.
Offline
#25 2003-10-14 10:24 am
Re: Can Mac beat Windows????
![]()
Next I notice when I return to play and load a saved game, this white box appears and tells me in many languages that I need to reboot. This happens alot. Mac bad.You definitely have 10.2 if you are seeing this white box with many languages because kernel panics prior to 10.2 would simply dump register and stack information onto the screen.
Dude, you're like the sherlock holmes of troubleshooting. That was so obvious and awesome.
It's a paradox of how sharply dull I am.
Offline

