Forums | MacLife
You are not logged in.
#1 2004-01-14 4:14 am
Circumcision... prevents AIDS?
I've been completely against circumcision for some time now. This might begin to change my view.
MALE CIRCUMCISION AND HIV
For years researchers have puzzled over why most West African countries have lower HIV-infection rates than southern and East African countries. They thought it might have something to do with the Muslim religion, widely practiced in West Africa, which imposes restrictions on women
Offline
#2 2004-01-14 4:37 am
- Short Circuit
- authorized airduct engineer
- From: UESC Marathon
- Registered: 2002-05-17
- Posts: 4739
Re: Circumcision... prevents AIDS?
Riiiight, and driving Fords makes you a zombie.
W
Frog7blast the ventcore!
Offline
#3 2004-01-14 5:29 am
Re: Circumcision... prevents AIDS?
I've been completely against circumcision for some time now. This might begin to change my view.
![]()
MALE CIRCUMCISION AND HIV
For years researchers have puzzled over why most West African countries have lower HIV-infection rates than southern and East African countries. They thought it might have something to do with the Muslim religion, widely practiced in West Africa, which imposes restrictions on women
Spirit was crushed; now is fading, But I want to help make things right.
Because I can see and I can feel, and you can see and you can feel
So why don't we both either stand up and fight
Or at least together we'll call it a night.Offline
#4 2004-01-14 5:32 am
- Stop the Robots
- I'm Jesus

- From: Michigan
- Registered: 2002-12-01
- Posts: 6727
Re: Circumcision... prevents AIDS?
Mitch: Dude, do you know anyone with AIDS?
Him: No
Mitch: Good, because you know me.
I am circumcised, and I don't have AIDS. Of course, I shouldn't unless I was born with it, which I wasn't.

Offline
#5 2004-01-14 6:33 am
Re: Circumcision... prevents AIDS?
I've been completely against circumcision for some time now. This might begin to change my view.
![]()
MALE CIRCUMCISION AND HIV
For years researchers have puzzled over why most West African countries have lower HIV-infection rates than southern and East African countries. They thought it might have something to do with the Muslim religion, widely practiced in West Africa, which imposes restrictions on womenOffline
#6 2004-01-14 6:50 am
- punkgeek
- born of frustration

- From: Dew Drop Inn
- Registered: 2001-05-28
- Posts: 3704
Re: Circumcision... prevents AIDS?
I saw something on tv about this a few years back, but my memory is shot. It has something to do with foreskin trapping bacteria...or something.
Very interesting stuff. 
"I also use lowercase christian when referring to her and people like her. To be Christian, they'd have to follow the example of Christ. These people are so un-Christlike, it's not even funny."
- robco
Offline
#7 2004-01-14 7:21 am
- SwisSlesS
- Member

- From: Home of the Massholes
- Registered: 2002-06-19
- Posts: 8307
Re: Circumcision... prevents AIDS?
I think it would be a much better idea to just not have unprotected sex with anyone who has AIDs.
"Hey, I'm circumcised, now I can smurf whoever I want!" 
I'm a dog, spelled backwards.
Offline
#8 2004-01-14 7:43 am
- pottymouth
- Uncreative
- Moderator

- From: JP, MA
- Registered: 2002-02-06
- Posts: 17410
- Website
Re: Circumcision... prevents AIDS?
"circumcision may cut a man
Offline
#9 2004-01-14 10:52 am
- Tria
- Minor Prophetess

- From: Madison, WI
- Registered: 2000-05-13
- Posts: 18087
Re: Circumcision... prevents AIDS?
Did that article have something more substantial than "the population % of AIDS in countries that practice circumcision is lower"? Because I could also claim that fair skin keeps you from getting AIDS; after all, the infection rate is much lower in the US and Europe than in Africa.

Offline
#10 2004-01-14 11:00 am
- Z
- Member

- From: Miami
- Registered: 2003-07-03
- Posts: 2257
Re: Circumcision... prevents AIDS?
Well, they did mention the part about receptors in the foreskin, so it appears that it's not just wild speculation based on a single statistic.
Offline
#11 2004-01-14 11:26 am
- DevoDoc
- Vardøger

- From: The East Wing
- Registered: 2003-05-27
- Posts: 2711
Re: Circumcision... prevents AIDS?
It makes sense to me that men practicing heterosexual intercourse may gain some protection by being circumcised. The mucosa on the glans is replaced by skin when you are circumcised, and skin serves as a protective barrier against HIV. It's pretty well established that you don't contract HIV by having infected body fluids splashed on your skin, but if it gets into your eyes, mouth, a cut, etc., you're at risk.
I would think this would offer no protection in homosexual intercourse, because the thinking there is that the virus usually invades through the rectal mucosa. Similarly, a circumcised male would be just as likely to pass HIV to a female partner as an uncircumcised male.
Offline
#12 2004-01-14 11:30 am
- ConnertheCat
- 7 Months Later

- From: Penfield, NY
- Registered: 2001-07-21
- Posts: 13405
Re: Circumcision... prevents AIDS?
Did that article have something more substantial than "the population % of AIDS in countries that practice circumcision is lower"? Because I could also claim that fair skin keeps you from getting AIDS; after all, the infection rate is much lower in the US and Europe than in Africa.
Wait... that's NOT true! 
Offline
#13 2004-01-14 11:40 am
- dreamkast0r
- Slack smurfer
- Registered: 2001-11-20
- Posts: 2634
Re: Circumcision... prevents AIDS?
Yeah, I agree with swiss. This is bad news because it's going to make some people think they might be able to "beat" getting aids. It's a very serious and scary thing, and I hope people don't take it lightly.
Offline
#14 2004-01-14 11:57 am
- watchout
- Member
- Registered: 2002-12-25
- Posts: 678
Re: Circumcision... prevents AIDS?
Well, I'm quite puzzled. If it were true, it really would provide a cheap and easy way to slow down propagation, but as Swiss pointed out, it could also lead to a false sense of security. As to whether or not circumcision really reduces the risk, I have serious doubts, but I'm no doctor or biologist, so I guess I'm not knowledgeable enough to judge. Although it does sound like some old propagandas the Church used to make: "Masturbating will make you go deaf... But it still could be possible i guess 
Offline
#15 2004-01-14 12:24 pm
Re: Circumcision... prevents AIDS?
Mitch: Dude, do you know anyone with AIDS?
Him: No
Mitch: Good, because you know me.
That man is hilarious!
"I don't have a girlfriend. I do know a girl who would be very angry if she heard I said that."
this is a random feature
Offline
#16 2004-01-14 12:27 pm
Re: Circumcision... prevents AIDS?
i suppose practicing safe sex would help even more than a circumcision.
I think it would be a much better idea to just not have unprotected sex with anyone who has AIDs.
this would help as well
also this sentence in the article struck me as odd:
or female genital mutilation, which is extremely dangerous
umm....not to mention just plain smurfing wrong!
(but i know i know, to each their own, blah blah blah)
Your hand, while firm and masculine, is soft as a velvet child.
Offline
#17 2004-01-14 12:53 pm
- XYZ
- Banned

- Registered: 2000-07-03
- Posts: 10881
Re: Circumcision... prevents AIDS?
Male genital mutilation is extremely dangerous, given that it's a cosmetic procedure. Infants are damaged by botched circumcisions every year, and some have even been given sex changes.
Circumcision is ritual genital mutilation. It is designed to reduce sexual appetite. Think I'm wrong? Graham Crackers were invented to curb sexual appetite. Pretzels were, too. One tenant of Judeo-Christian belief is the idea that the human body's needs/urges are "base" and that in order to be more spiritually pure, one must reject them. That's why Jews have ritual fasting, circumcision, and things like the Mosaic Code. That's why Catholic priests are supposed to be celibate. While circumcision doesn't reduce sexual appetite, it does reduce sexual pleasure. The foreskin protected the glans - the most sensitive part of the penis, from abrasion - abrasion that causes the skin to toughen and lose sensitivity.
The medical community makes a lot of money from the procedure.
Lesbians have the lowest HIV infection rate. If people want to prevent HIV infection, male babies will have to be given sex changes. I'm sure the percentage figure would be very compelling. 
there's really no need for all of this
Offline
#18 2004-01-14 1:12 pm
- Og
- Member

- From: Ha!
- Registered: 2002-01-18
- Posts: 5133
Re: Circumcision... prevents AIDS?
Circumcision is ritual genital mutilation.
a bit... "testy", aren't we?
It is designed to reduce sexual appetite. Think I'm wrong? Graham Crackers were invented to curb sexual appetite. Pretzels were, too.
Unless you can provide a rational source for this claim, not only will I think you're wrong, but I'll think you're more of a smurfing idiot than I do now. Pretzels? Graham crackers? Why? Because anyone eating graham crackers would think of Billy Graham, and that would be more effective than salt-peter?
The foreskin protected the glans - the most sensitive part of the penis, from abrasion - abrasion that causes the skin to toughen and lose sensitivity.
If I were any more sensitive, I'd probaly go nucking futs.
If people want to prevent HIV infection, male babies will have to be given sex changes.
You first.
please don't come back to 54
tito
Offline
#19 2004-01-14 1:19 pm
- Piltdownman84
- Member
- From: Victoria, bc
- Registered: 2001-08-28
- Posts: 953
Re: Circumcision... prevents AIDS?
Well, I'm quite puzzled. If it were true, it really would provide a cheap and easy way to slow down propagation, but as Swiss pointed out, it could also lead to a false sense of security. As to whether or not circumcision really reduces the risk, I have serious doubts, but I'm no doctor or biologist, so I guess I'm not knowledgeable enough to judge. Although it does sound like some old propagandas the Church used to make: "Masturbating will make you go deaf... But it still could be possible i guess
I thought it was blind. Which would make sence if you look at all the people with glasses these days. j/k
"When did the future switch from being a promise to being a threat?"
Offline
#20 2004-01-14 1:29 pm
- Z
- Member

- From: Miami
- Registered: 2003-07-03
- Posts: 2257
Re: Circumcision... prevents AIDS?
It is designed to reduce sexual appetite. Think I'm wrong? Graham Crackers were invented to curb sexual appetite. Pretzels were, too.
Unless you can provide a rational source for this claim, not only will I think you're wrong, but I'll think you're more of a smurfing idiot than I do now. Pretzels? Graham crackers? Why? Because anyone eating graham crackers would think of Billy Graham, and that would be more effective than salt-peter?
![]()
Graham crackers
Pretzels
It appears he's 1-for-2 there.
Offline
#21 2004-01-14 2:00 pm
- Og
- Member

- From: Ha!
- Registered: 2002-01-18
- Posts: 5133
Re: Circumcision... prevents AIDS?
Graham crackers
Pretzels
It appears he's 1-for-2 there.
No, he's not. It stated on the Straight Dope that, "A forebear of the hairy-palms-and-blindness school of moral instruction, Graham said excessive carnal exercise would cause indigestion, headache, feebleness of circulation, pulmonary consumption, spinal diseases, epilepsy, insanity, and early death of offspring, among other things. He thought men should remain virgins until age 30 and then should make love only once a month--not at all if they were sickly." and that "...he was a little goofy on the question of sex." Graham clearly needed to get laid.
Graham crackers may have been invented by a cracker-factory escapee to curb sexual appetite, but they are obviously not effective. XYZ clearly implies that those foods are as effective as circumcision (if said procedure does indeed "reduce sexual appetite", a theory I can neither affirm nor deny but sounds ludicrous to me.)
So he is WRONG. Based on the argument presented by Graham, those of us who eat whole wheat bread should also have diminished sexual appetite. I eat whole wheat breads, and I'm hornier than a bull.
please don't come back to 54
tito
Offline
#22 2004-01-14 2:14 pm
- Z
- Member

- From: Miami
- Registered: 2003-07-03
- Posts: 2257
Re: Circumcision... prevents AIDS?
I don't think that's how he meant it. The way I read XYZ's post is that Graham invented graham crackers because he thought they would curb sexual appetite, even though they don't. In that respect, the Straight Dope corroborates that point.
Offline
#23 2004-01-14 2:24 pm
Re: Circumcision... prevents AIDS?
These tests could not go on here since they involved paying males to have sex with known hiv positive females.
I'm so glad that I'm not so bad off that I have to resort to this.
Your life has to be the absolute most smurf life in the world to have sex with an HIV+ person on purpose with no protection for money.
"The only thing better than a woman you can control in bed, is one that you can't."
Offline
#24 2004-01-14 2:28 pm
- TheConfuzed1
- Faking Sanity

- Registered: 2000-04-19
- Posts: 20194
Re: Circumcision... prevents AIDS?
I think it would be a much better idea to just not have unprotected sex with anyone who has AIDs.
"Hey, I'm circumcised, now I can smurf whoever I want!"
Hey baby, so am I! 
The storm starts when the drops start dropping. When the drops stop dropping, the storm starts stopping.
Last Fm
Offline
#25 2004-01-14 2:31 pm
- TheConfuzed1
- Faking Sanity

- Registered: 2000-04-19
- Posts: 20194
Re: Circumcision... prevents AIDS?
I'm guessing that the reason for this is because it is not as likely for fluid to enter a man's penis during sex as it is for fluid to enter a woman's vagina. And without the foreskin there is nothing for the virus to "attach" to? 
The storm starts when the drops start dropping. When the drops stop dropping, the storm starts stopping.
Last Fm
Offline


