Forums | MacLife

matt wrote:

Certain forums had/have been basically abandoned or get little-to-no traffic-- for example, many of the gaming forums(which have yet to be fully addressed). [MA] UT - Dark Squad has not had a single post in almost two years. That being the case, does it deserve its own forum? Shouldn't the forum list be short and easy to navigate and not have a lot of dead rooms where no one goes?

Those gaming forums you speak of are dead because they don't show up for 99.9% of the people here.  How are we supposed to know they exist if they are hidden?  They used to be displayed for everyone, but only accessable to members, but now they are simply gone.  Frankly, I forgot they even existed. Why were they restricted access in the first place?

Here's another vote against combining Unplugged and the Rant Room.

Also, "Everyday Tech" doesn't exactly scream "Tech Support". I predict that n00bs looking for a little help won't be able to find it any better than they found "Balloon Help".

DukeofNuke wrote:

Also, "Everyday Tech" doesn't exactly scream "Tech Support". I predict that n00bs looking for a little help won't be able to find it any better than they found "Balloon Help".

The point of the change was not to rename Balloon Help.

The point was to get rid of Balloon Help, and have people just ask questions in the forum related to the subject they are asking about.

Miles wrote:

Mymac4ever wrote:

That does sound like a good explenation but I wonder if the unanswered threads will disapear even if you change the line up. How about adding a function to show unanswered threads? I'm not sure how that works or if it even works with the current version of the forums but I have seen it implementet in the swedish forums "99.se"

We have absolutely no ability to change the forum software.  Happily, that function already exists: http://www.maclife.com/forums/search/show_unanswered

Well then it should be at the top because I hadn't noticed it before. Who knows, maybee people start using it if they could find it. It IS more natural to look for useful links/buttons at the top of the page than at the bottom.

Um, no.

,xtG
.tsooJ

matt wrote:

Orion wrote:

matt wrote:

Certain forums had/have been basically abandoned or get little-to-no traffic-- for example, many of the gaming forums(which have yet to be fully addressed). [MA] UT - Dark Squad has not had a single post in almost two years. That being the case, does it deserve its own forum? Shouldn't the forum list be short and easy to navigate and not have a lot of dead rooms where no one goes?

Those gaming forums you speak of are dead because they don't show up for 99.9% of the people here.  How are we supposed to know they exist if they are hidden?  They used to be displayed for everyone, but only accessable to members, but now they are simply gone.  Frankly, I forgot they even existed. Why were they restricted access in the first place?

I can browse those forums if I'm not logged in.

I don't see the Dark Squad forum.  Or the Eclipse Squad forum.  Or the Omega Squad forum...or the Alpha Squad forum...or the X Squad forum.

Or, for that matter, the [MA] Officers' Club, but I haven't seen that one in a long time. 

I know they were there once but I can't see them now.

Last edited by Daniel (2007-09-12 1:49 pm)

mahakali wrote:

I'll be the anarchy if you want me to.

We should explore this in depth.

Hey, it'll be fun.
I'm thinking something like laptop questions in Forum Feedback.
The proper syntax in vi to do a file duplicate erasure and backup on a 40 drive server farm in Unplugged.
Pictures and stories of your new kitty in Minithink.

The kitty stories can be minithink-worthy if done right.

Daniel wrote:

matt wrote:

Orion wrote:

Those gaming forums you speak of are dead because they don't show up for 99.9% of the people here.  How are we supposed to know they exist if they are hidden?  They used to be displayed for everyone, but only accessable to members, but now they are simply gone.  Frankly, I forgot they even existed. Why were they restricted access in the first place?

I can browse those forums if I'm not logged in.

I don't see the Dark Squad forum.  Or the Eclipse Squad forum.  Or the Omega Squad forum...or the Alpha Squad forum...or the X Squad forum.

Or, for that matter, the [MA] Officers' Club, but I haven't seen that one in a long time. 

I know they were there once but I can't see them now.

Exactly, Dan.  They used to be there, but are not anymore.  Matt stated that the last post was over two years ago.  No one can post if they can't access them, right? 

Mac|Life
- Mac|Life Readers: Discussion of Mac|Life magazine & site
- Forum Feedback: Discussion of Mac|Life forums

Digital|Life
- In Tech News: Discussion of official announcements, headlines & rumors
- Everyday Tech: Discussion of help issues & general topics related to technology systems, devices & software, particularly tethered systems & devices
- On-the-Go: Discussion of help issues & general topics related to mobile technology devices, especially Laptops, iPods & iPhones
- The Pro Shop: Discussion of Publishing, Multimedia, Audio, Graphic Design, web design topics
- Programming: Discussion of application development & web development topics
- Networking & Servers: Discussion of network & server management topics
- Games: General discussion of video games

Real|Life
- Unplugged: Discussion of life in general
- Student Lounge: Discussion of life as a student
- Ministry of Free Thought: Discussion of politics & religion

Alternative|Life
- Boot Camp: Discussion of Windows, Linux & Unix topics
- Vintage Apple: Discussion of OS 9 or under & pre-USB native hardware
- Hardware Hacking: Discussion of hardware construction and alteration

Team Mac|Life
- Folding@Home: Team Mac|Life Folding@Home discussion forum
- SETI@Home: Team Mac|Life SETI@Home discussion forum

Clan MacAddict/Clan Mac|Life
Various Clan related forums & topics

Rant rooms topics were simply archived in Unplugged and it's too late for them to be unarchived. Unplugged was simply chosen as the archival location as most topics in there were of a life in general nature. If it's contents had mostly been technical in nature, we would've archived it in Everyday Tech. If they had mostly been political, we would've archived them in Minithink.

As has been repeated over and over The Rant Room's function has been spread to ALL FORUMS. You rant about life in general in Unplugged as it's the life in general forum. You rant about Bush in Minithink as it's the politics and religion forum. You rant about the iPhone in On-the-Go because it's the Laptop, iPod, iPhone, etc. forum. You rant about Halo 3 taking forever in Games because it the video games forum. You rant abut what a drag school is in student lounge be cause it's the student life forum. And so on and so forth.